Bilinear Constraints upon the Correlation Contribution to the Electron-Electron Repulsion Energy as a Functional of the One-Electron Reduced Density Matrix

Jerzy Cioslowski, Zsuzsanna Mihálka, A. Szabados

Research output: Article

Abstract

Perturbative analysis of the functional U[n, ψ] that yields the correlation component U of the electron-electron repulsion energy in terms of the vectors ψ(1) and n of the natural spinorbitals and their occupation numbers (the 1-matrix functional) facilitates examination of the flaws inherent to the present implementations of the density matrix functional theory. Recognizing that the practical usefulness of any approximate 1-matrix functional hinges upon its capability of exactly reproducing the leading contribution to U at the limit of vanishing electron-electron interactions gives rise to asymptotic bilinear constraints for the (exact or model) 2-cumulant G2 that enters the expression for U. The asymptotic behavior of certain blocks of G2 is found to be equally important. These identities, which are obtained for both the single-determinantal and a model multideterminantal cases, take precedence over the linear constraints commonly enforced in the course of approximate construction of such functionals. This observation reveals the futility of designing sophisticated approximations tailored for the second-order contribution to G2 while neglecting proper formulation of the respective first-order contribution that in the case of the so-called JKL-only functionals requires abandoning the JK-dependence altogether. It has its repercussions not only for the functionals of the PNOF family but also for the expressions involving only the L-type two-electron repulsion integrals (in the guise of their exchange counterparts) that account only for the correlation effects due to electrons with antiparallel spins and are well-defined only for spin-unpolarized and high-spin systems (yielding vanishing U for the latter). ©

Original languageEnglish
JournalJournal of chemical theory and computation
DOIs
Publication statusAccepted/In press - jan. 1 2019

Fingerprint

Electrons
functionals
electrons
Electron-electron interactions
energy
Hinges
hinges
matrices
occupation
electron scattering
Defects
examination
formulations
defects
approximation

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Computer Science Applications
  • Physical and Theoretical Chemistry

Cite this

@article{4861f1613ae14671b461b4085e050edf,
title = "Bilinear Constraints upon the Correlation Contribution to the Electron-Electron Repulsion Energy as a Functional of the One-Electron Reduced Density Matrix",
abstract = "Perturbative analysis of the functional U[n, ψ] that yields the correlation component U of the electron-electron repulsion energy in terms of the vectors ψ(1) and n of the natural spinorbitals and their occupation numbers (the 1-matrix functional) facilitates examination of the flaws inherent to the present implementations of the density matrix functional theory. Recognizing that the practical usefulness of any approximate 1-matrix functional hinges upon its capability of exactly reproducing the leading contribution to U at the limit of vanishing electron-electron interactions gives rise to asymptotic bilinear constraints for the (exact or model) 2-cumulant G2 that enters the expression for U. The asymptotic behavior of certain blocks of G2 is found to be equally important. These identities, which are obtained for both the single-determinantal and a model multideterminantal cases, take precedence over the linear constraints commonly enforced in the course of approximate construction of such functionals. This observation reveals the futility of designing sophisticated approximations tailored for the second-order contribution to G2 while neglecting proper formulation of the respective first-order contribution that in the case of the so-called JKL-only functionals requires abandoning the JK-dependence altogether. It has its repercussions not only for the functionals of the PNOF family but also for the expressions involving only the L-type two-electron repulsion integrals (in the guise of their exchange counterparts) that account only for the correlation effects due to electrons with antiparallel spins and are well-defined only for spin-unpolarized and high-spin systems (yielding vanishing U for the latter). {\circledC}",
author = "Jerzy Cioslowski and Zsuzsanna Mih{\'a}lka and A. Szabados",
year = "2019",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1021/acs.jctc.9b00443",
language = "English",
journal = "Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation",
issn = "1549-9618",
publisher = "American Chemical Society",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Bilinear Constraints upon the Correlation Contribution to the Electron-Electron Repulsion Energy as a Functional of the One-Electron Reduced Density Matrix

AU - Cioslowski, Jerzy

AU - Mihálka, Zsuzsanna

AU - Szabados, A.

PY - 2019/1/1

Y1 - 2019/1/1

N2 - Perturbative analysis of the functional U[n, ψ] that yields the correlation component U of the electron-electron repulsion energy in terms of the vectors ψ(1) and n of the natural spinorbitals and their occupation numbers (the 1-matrix functional) facilitates examination of the flaws inherent to the present implementations of the density matrix functional theory. Recognizing that the practical usefulness of any approximate 1-matrix functional hinges upon its capability of exactly reproducing the leading contribution to U at the limit of vanishing electron-electron interactions gives rise to asymptotic bilinear constraints for the (exact or model) 2-cumulant G2 that enters the expression for U. The asymptotic behavior of certain blocks of G2 is found to be equally important. These identities, which are obtained for both the single-determinantal and a model multideterminantal cases, take precedence over the linear constraints commonly enforced in the course of approximate construction of such functionals. This observation reveals the futility of designing sophisticated approximations tailored for the second-order contribution to G2 while neglecting proper formulation of the respective first-order contribution that in the case of the so-called JKL-only functionals requires abandoning the JK-dependence altogether. It has its repercussions not only for the functionals of the PNOF family but also for the expressions involving only the L-type two-electron repulsion integrals (in the guise of their exchange counterparts) that account only for the correlation effects due to electrons with antiparallel spins and are well-defined only for spin-unpolarized and high-spin systems (yielding vanishing U for the latter). ©

AB - Perturbative analysis of the functional U[n, ψ] that yields the correlation component U of the electron-electron repulsion energy in terms of the vectors ψ(1) and n of the natural spinorbitals and their occupation numbers (the 1-matrix functional) facilitates examination of the flaws inherent to the present implementations of the density matrix functional theory. Recognizing that the practical usefulness of any approximate 1-matrix functional hinges upon its capability of exactly reproducing the leading contribution to U at the limit of vanishing electron-electron interactions gives rise to asymptotic bilinear constraints for the (exact or model) 2-cumulant G2 that enters the expression for U. The asymptotic behavior of certain blocks of G2 is found to be equally important. These identities, which are obtained for both the single-determinantal and a model multideterminantal cases, take precedence over the linear constraints commonly enforced in the course of approximate construction of such functionals. This observation reveals the futility of designing sophisticated approximations tailored for the second-order contribution to G2 while neglecting proper formulation of the respective first-order contribution that in the case of the so-called JKL-only functionals requires abandoning the JK-dependence altogether. It has its repercussions not only for the functionals of the PNOF family but also for the expressions involving only the L-type two-electron repulsion integrals (in the guise of their exchange counterparts) that account only for the correlation effects due to electrons with antiparallel spins and are well-defined only for spin-unpolarized and high-spin systems (yielding vanishing U for the latter). ©

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85071005671&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85071005671&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1021/acs.jctc.9b00443

DO - 10.1021/acs.jctc.9b00443

M3 - Article

JO - Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation

JF - Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation

SN - 1549-9618

ER -