Spider web survey or whole plant visual sampling? Impact assessment of Bt corn on non-target predatory insects with two concurrent methods.

Ferenc Tóth, Krisztina Arpás, Dóra Szekeres, Ferenc Kádár, Ferenc Szentkirályi, Agnes Szénási, J. Kiss

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

6 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Impact assessment studies rely on relevant sampling methods. Correct evaluation of methods can be done by their concurrent use in the same sampling site and period. Collecting webs of Theridion impressum L. Koch (Araneae: Theridiidae) may serve as an arthropod sampling method: empty cuticles of prey items remain attached to the back side of the leaves with adhesive silk. Our study aimed to compare the applicability of the two methods concurrently (spider web survey and whole plant visual sampling) in a risk assessment study. The spider web survey recorded more predatory insect families than the whole plant visual sampling. Both methods were able to detect significant differences in the quantity of predatory insects in Bt vs. isogenic plots, but not in the same taxa (Nabidae: spider-web, 2001, Bt > Iso; Coccinellidae: plant sampling, 2001, Iso > Bt; Welsh-test, P <0.05); thus, they could not confirm each other. The lack of confirmation can be explained by differences in the sensitivity and selectivity of the two methods. A web survey of T. impressum has the practical advantage that although we concentrate only on the one species during field sampling, we gain additional information on a wide range of foliage-dwelling arthropods. Due to several biological uncertainties, interpretation and explanation of the results remain problematic. Thus, additional research--based on in-situ observation and recording of T. impressum-prey interactions--is necessary before we could propose web survey method as a complementary tool in ecological impact assessment.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)225-231
Number of pages7
JournalEnvironmental Biosafety Research
Volume3
Issue number4
Publication statusPublished - Oct 2004

Fingerprint

spider web
predatory insects
Spiders
Zea mays
Insects
maize
insect
Sampling
corn
sampling
Arthropods
arthropod
methodology
arthropods
Theridion
Nabidae
Silk
Theridiidae
survey method
Adhesives

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Environmental Science(all)
  • Agricultural and Biological Sciences(all)
  • Safety Research
  • Biomedical Engineering
  • Safety, Risk, Reliability and Quality
  • Biotechnology

Cite this

Spider web survey or whole plant visual sampling? Impact assessment of Bt corn on non-target predatory insects with two concurrent methods. / Tóth, Ferenc; Arpás, Krisztina; Szekeres, Dóra; Kádár, Ferenc; Szentkirályi, Ferenc; Szénási, Agnes; Kiss, J.

In: Environmental Biosafety Research, Vol. 3, No. 4, 10.2004, p. 225-231.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Tóth, Ferenc ; Arpás, Krisztina ; Szekeres, Dóra ; Kádár, Ferenc ; Szentkirályi, Ferenc ; Szénási, Agnes ; Kiss, J. / Spider web survey or whole plant visual sampling? Impact assessment of Bt corn on non-target predatory insects with two concurrent methods. In: Environmental Biosafety Research. 2004 ; Vol. 3, No. 4. pp. 225-231.
@article{fde0e0e605fc4e81891bfd64271fa348,
title = "Spider web survey or whole plant visual sampling? Impact assessment of Bt corn on non-target predatory insects with two concurrent methods.",
abstract = "Impact assessment studies rely on relevant sampling methods. Correct evaluation of methods can be done by their concurrent use in the same sampling site and period. Collecting webs of Theridion impressum L. Koch (Araneae: Theridiidae) may serve as an arthropod sampling method: empty cuticles of prey items remain attached to the back side of the leaves with adhesive silk. Our study aimed to compare the applicability of the two methods concurrently (spider web survey and whole plant visual sampling) in a risk assessment study. The spider web survey recorded more predatory insect families than the whole plant visual sampling. Both methods were able to detect significant differences in the quantity of predatory insects in Bt vs. isogenic plots, but not in the same taxa (Nabidae: spider-web, 2001, Bt > Iso; Coccinellidae: plant sampling, 2001, Iso > Bt; Welsh-test, P <0.05); thus, they could not confirm each other. The lack of confirmation can be explained by differences in the sensitivity and selectivity of the two methods. A web survey of T. impressum has the practical advantage that although we concentrate only on the one species during field sampling, we gain additional information on a wide range of foliage-dwelling arthropods. Due to several biological uncertainties, interpretation and explanation of the results remain problematic. Thus, additional research--based on in-situ observation and recording of T. impressum-prey interactions--is necessary before we could propose web survey method as a complementary tool in ecological impact assessment.",
author = "Ferenc T{\'o}th and Krisztina Arp{\'a}s and D{\'o}ra Szekeres and Ferenc K{\'a}d{\'a}r and Ferenc Szentkir{\'a}lyi and Agnes Sz{\'e}n{\'a}si and J. Kiss",
year = "2004",
month = "10",
language = "English",
volume = "3",
pages = "225--231",
journal = "Environmental Biosafety Research",
issn = "1635-7922",
publisher = "EDP Sciences",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Spider web survey or whole plant visual sampling? Impact assessment of Bt corn on non-target predatory insects with two concurrent methods.

AU - Tóth, Ferenc

AU - Arpás, Krisztina

AU - Szekeres, Dóra

AU - Kádár, Ferenc

AU - Szentkirályi, Ferenc

AU - Szénási, Agnes

AU - Kiss, J.

PY - 2004/10

Y1 - 2004/10

N2 - Impact assessment studies rely on relevant sampling methods. Correct evaluation of methods can be done by their concurrent use in the same sampling site and period. Collecting webs of Theridion impressum L. Koch (Araneae: Theridiidae) may serve as an arthropod sampling method: empty cuticles of prey items remain attached to the back side of the leaves with adhesive silk. Our study aimed to compare the applicability of the two methods concurrently (spider web survey and whole plant visual sampling) in a risk assessment study. The spider web survey recorded more predatory insect families than the whole plant visual sampling. Both methods were able to detect significant differences in the quantity of predatory insects in Bt vs. isogenic plots, but not in the same taxa (Nabidae: spider-web, 2001, Bt > Iso; Coccinellidae: plant sampling, 2001, Iso > Bt; Welsh-test, P <0.05); thus, they could not confirm each other. The lack of confirmation can be explained by differences in the sensitivity and selectivity of the two methods. A web survey of T. impressum has the practical advantage that although we concentrate only on the one species during field sampling, we gain additional information on a wide range of foliage-dwelling arthropods. Due to several biological uncertainties, interpretation and explanation of the results remain problematic. Thus, additional research--based on in-situ observation and recording of T. impressum-prey interactions--is necessary before we could propose web survey method as a complementary tool in ecological impact assessment.

AB - Impact assessment studies rely on relevant sampling methods. Correct evaluation of methods can be done by their concurrent use in the same sampling site and period. Collecting webs of Theridion impressum L. Koch (Araneae: Theridiidae) may serve as an arthropod sampling method: empty cuticles of prey items remain attached to the back side of the leaves with adhesive silk. Our study aimed to compare the applicability of the two methods concurrently (spider web survey and whole plant visual sampling) in a risk assessment study. The spider web survey recorded more predatory insect families than the whole plant visual sampling. Both methods were able to detect significant differences in the quantity of predatory insects in Bt vs. isogenic plots, but not in the same taxa (Nabidae: spider-web, 2001, Bt > Iso; Coccinellidae: plant sampling, 2001, Iso > Bt; Welsh-test, P <0.05); thus, they could not confirm each other. The lack of confirmation can be explained by differences in the sensitivity and selectivity of the two methods. A web survey of T. impressum has the practical advantage that although we concentrate only on the one species during field sampling, we gain additional information on a wide range of foliage-dwelling arthropods. Due to several biological uncertainties, interpretation and explanation of the results remain problematic. Thus, additional research--based on in-situ observation and recording of T. impressum-prey interactions--is necessary before we could propose web survey method as a complementary tool in ecological impact assessment.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=25444472408&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=25444472408&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

VL - 3

SP - 225

EP - 231

JO - Environmental Biosafety Research

JF - Environmental Biosafety Research

SN - 1635-7922

IS - 4

ER -