Spallation recoil II: Xenon evidence for young SiC grains

U. Ott, M. Altmaier, U. Herpers, J. Kuhnhenn, S. Merchel, R. Michel, R. K. Mohapatra

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

20 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

We have determined the recoil range of spallation xenon produced by irradiation of Ba glass targets with ∼1190 and ∼268 MeV protons, using a catcher technique, where spallation products are measured in target and catcher foils. The inferred range for 126Xe produced in silicon carbide is ∼0.19 μm, which implies retention of ∼70% for 126Xe produced in "typical" presolar silicon carbide grains of 1 μm size. Recoil loss of spallation xenon poses a significantly smaller problem than loss of the spallation neon from SiC grains. Ranges differ for the various Xe isotopes and scale approximately linearly as function of the mass difference between the target element, Ba, and the product. As a consequence, SiC grains of various sizes will have differences in spallation Xe composition. In an additional experiment at ∼66 MeV, where the recoil ranges of 22Na and 127Xe produced on Ba glass were determined using γ-spectrometry, we found no evidence for recoil ranges being systematically different at this lower energy. We have used the new data to put constraints on the possible presolar age of the SiC grains analyzed for Xe by Lewis et al. (1994). Uncertainties in the composition of the approximately normal Xe component in SiC (Xe-N) constitute the most serious problem in determining an age, surpassing remaining uncertainties in Xe retention and production rate. A possible interpretation is that spallation contributions are negligible and that trapped 124Xe/ 126Xe is ∼5% lower in Xe-N than in Q-Xe. But also for other reasonable assumptions for the 124Xe/126Xe ratio in Xe-N (e.g., as in Q-Xe), inferred exposure ages are considerably shorter than theoretically expected lifetimes for interstellar grains. A short presolar age is in line with observations by others (appearance, grain size distribution) that indicate little processing in the interstellar medium (ISM) of surviving (crystalline) SiC. This may be due to amorphization of SiC in the ISM on a much shorter time scale than destruction, with amorphous SiC not surviving processing in the early solar system. A large supply of relatively young grains may be connected to the proposed starburst origin (Clayton 2003) for the parent stars of the mainstream SiC grains.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1635-1652
Number of pages18
JournalMeteoritics and Planetary Science
Volume40
Issue number11
Publication statusPublished - Nov 2005

Fingerprint

xenon
spallation
silicon
catchers
glass
neon
silicon carbides
solar system
spectrometry
irradiation
grain size
isotope
timescale
products
young
destruction
foils
isotopes
energy
experiment

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Geophysics

Cite this

Ott, U., Altmaier, M., Herpers, U., Kuhnhenn, J., Merchel, S., Michel, R., & Mohapatra, R. K. (2005). Spallation recoil II: Xenon evidence for young SiC grains. Meteoritics and Planetary Science, 40(11), 1635-1652.

Spallation recoil II : Xenon evidence for young SiC grains. / Ott, U.; Altmaier, M.; Herpers, U.; Kuhnhenn, J.; Merchel, S.; Michel, R.; Mohapatra, R. K.

In: Meteoritics and Planetary Science, Vol. 40, No. 11, 11.2005, p. 1635-1652.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Ott, U, Altmaier, M, Herpers, U, Kuhnhenn, J, Merchel, S, Michel, R & Mohapatra, RK 2005, 'Spallation recoil II: Xenon evidence for young SiC grains', Meteoritics and Planetary Science, vol. 40, no. 11, pp. 1635-1652.
Ott U, Altmaier M, Herpers U, Kuhnhenn J, Merchel S, Michel R et al. Spallation recoil II: Xenon evidence for young SiC grains. Meteoritics and Planetary Science. 2005 Nov;40(11):1635-1652.
Ott, U. ; Altmaier, M. ; Herpers, U. ; Kuhnhenn, J. ; Merchel, S. ; Michel, R. ; Mohapatra, R. K. / Spallation recoil II : Xenon evidence for young SiC grains. In: Meteoritics and Planetary Science. 2005 ; Vol. 40, No. 11. pp. 1635-1652.
@article{0e4b9c11ebf44f919ccf05676ffabdb5,
title = "Spallation recoil II: Xenon evidence for young SiC grains",
abstract = "We have determined the recoil range of spallation xenon produced by irradiation of Ba glass targets with ∼1190 and ∼268 MeV protons, using a catcher technique, where spallation products are measured in target and catcher foils. The inferred range for 126Xe produced in silicon carbide is ∼0.19 μm, which implies retention of ∼70{\%} for 126Xe produced in {"}typical{"} presolar silicon carbide grains of 1 μm size. Recoil loss of spallation xenon poses a significantly smaller problem than loss of the spallation neon from SiC grains. Ranges differ for the various Xe isotopes and scale approximately linearly as function of the mass difference between the target element, Ba, and the product. As a consequence, SiC grains of various sizes will have differences in spallation Xe composition. In an additional experiment at ∼66 MeV, where the recoil ranges of 22Na and 127Xe produced on Ba glass were determined using γ-spectrometry, we found no evidence for recoil ranges being systematically different at this lower energy. We have used the new data to put constraints on the possible presolar age of the SiC grains analyzed for Xe by Lewis et al. (1994). Uncertainties in the composition of the approximately normal Xe component in SiC (Xe-N) constitute the most serious problem in determining an age, surpassing remaining uncertainties in Xe retention and production rate. A possible interpretation is that spallation contributions are negligible and that trapped 124Xe/ 126Xe is ∼5{\%} lower in Xe-N than in Q-Xe. But also for other reasonable assumptions for the 124Xe/126Xe ratio in Xe-N (e.g., as in Q-Xe), inferred exposure ages are considerably shorter than theoretically expected lifetimes for interstellar grains. A short presolar age is in line with observations by others (appearance, grain size distribution) that indicate little processing in the interstellar medium (ISM) of surviving (crystalline) SiC. This may be due to amorphization of SiC in the ISM on a much shorter time scale than destruction, with amorphous SiC not surviving processing in the early solar system. A large supply of relatively young grains may be connected to the proposed starburst origin (Clayton 2003) for the parent stars of the mainstream SiC grains.",
author = "U. Ott and M. Altmaier and U. Herpers and J. Kuhnhenn and S. Merchel and R. Michel and Mohapatra, {R. K.}",
year = "2005",
month = "11",
language = "English",
volume = "40",
pages = "1635--1652",
journal = "Meteoritics and Planetary Science",
issn = "1086-9379",
publisher = "The University of Arkansas Press",
number = "11",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Spallation recoil II

T2 - Xenon evidence for young SiC grains

AU - Ott, U.

AU - Altmaier, M.

AU - Herpers, U.

AU - Kuhnhenn, J.

AU - Merchel, S.

AU - Michel, R.

AU - Mohapatra, R. K.

PY - 2005/11

Y1 - 2005/11

N2 - We have determined the recoil range of spallation xenon produced by irradiation of Ba glass targets with ∼1190 and ∼268 MeV protons, using a catcher technique, where spallation products are measured in target and catcher foils. The inferred range for 126Xe produced in silicon carbide is ∼0.19 μm, which implies retention of ∼70% for 126Xe produced in "typical" presolar silicon carbide grains of 1 μm size. Recoil loss of spallation xenon poses a significantly smaller problem than loss of the spallation neon from SiC grains. Ranges differ for the various Xe isotopes and scale approximately linearly as function of the mass difference between the target element, Ba, and the product. As a consequence, SiC grains of various sizes will have differences in spallation Xe composition. In an additional experiment at ∼66 MeV, where the recoil ranges of 22Na and 127Xe produced on Ba glass were determined using γ-spectrometry, we found no evidence for recoil ranges being systematically different at this lower energy. We have used the new data to put constraints on the possible presolar age of the SiC grains analyzed for Xe by Lewis et al. (1994). Uncertainties in the composition of the approximately normal Xe component in SiC (Xe-N) constitute the most serious problem in determining an age, surpassing remaining uncertainties in Xe retention and production rate. A possible interpretation is that spallation contributions are negligible and that trapped 124Xe/ 126Xe is ∼5% lower in Xe-N than in Q-Xe. But also for other reasonable assumptions for the 124Xe/126Xe ratio in Xe-N (e.g., as in Q-Xe), inferred exposure ages are considerably shorter than theoretically expected lifetimes for interstellar grains. A short presolar age is in line with observations by others (appearance, grain size distribution) that indicate little processing in the interstellar medium (ISM) of surviving (crystalline) SiC. This may be due to amorphization of SiC in the ISM on a much shorter time scale than destruction, with amorphous SiC not surviving processing in the early solar system. A large supply of relatively young grains may be connected to the proposed starburst origin (Clayton 2003) for the parent stars of the mainstream SiC grains.

AB - We have determined the recoil range of spallation xenon produced by irradiation of Ba glass targets with ∼1190 and ∼268 MeV protons, using a catcher technique, where spallation products are measured in target and catcher foils. The inferred range for 126Xe produced in silicon carbide is ∼0.19 μm, which implies retention of ∼70% for 126Xe produced in "typical" presolar silicon carbide grains of 1 μm size. Recoil loss of spallation xenon poses a significantly smaller problem than loss of the spallation neon from SiC grains. Ranges differ for the various Xe isotopes and scale approximately linearly as function of the mass difference between the target element, Ba, and the product. As a consequence, SiC grains of various sizes will have differences in spallation Xe composition. In an additional experiment at ∼66 MeV, where the recoil ranges of 22Na and 127Xe produced on Ba glass were determined using γ-spectrometry, we found no evidence for recoil ranges being systematically different at this lower energy. We have used the new data to put constraints on the possible presolar age of the SiC grains analyzed for Xe by Lewis et al. (1994). Uncertainties in the composition of the approximately normal Xe component in SiC (Xe-N) constitute the most serious problem in determining an age, surpassing remaining uncertainties in Xe retention and production rate. A possible interpretation is that spallation contributions are negligible and that trapped 124Xe/ 126Xe is ∼5% lower in Xe-N than in Q-Xe. But also for other reasonable assumptions for the 124Xe/126Xe ratio in Xe-N (e.g., as in Q-Xe), inferred exposure ages are considerably shorter than theoretically expected lifetimes for interstellar grains. A short presolar age is in line with observations by others (appearance, grain size distribution) that indicate little processing in the interstellar medium (ISM) of surviving (crystalline) SiC. This may be due to amorphization of SiC in the ISM on a much shorter time scale than destruction, with amorphous SiC not surviving processing in the early solar system. A large supply of relatively young grains may be connected to the proposed starburst origin (Clayton 2003) for the parent stars of the mainstream SiC grains.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=31344451530&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=31344451530&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:31344451530

VL - 40

SP - 1635

EP - 1652

JO - Meteoritics and Planetary Science

JF - Meteoritics and Planetary Science

SN - 1086-9379

IS - 11

ER -