SIMEX for correction of dietary exposure effects with Box-Cox transformed data

on behalf of the I.Family Consortium

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Modelling dietary data, and especially 24-hr dietary recall (24HDR) data, is a challenge. Ignoring the inherent measurement error (ME) leads to biased effect estimates when the association between an exposure and an outcome is investigated. We propose an adapted simulation extrapolation (SIMEX) algorithm for modelling dietary exposures. For this purpose, we exploit the ME model of the NCI method where we assume the assumption of normally distributed errors of the reported intake on the Box-Cox transformed scale and of unbiased recalls on the original scale. According to the SIMEX algorithm, remeasurements of the observed data with additional ME are generated in order to estimate the association between the level of ME and the resulting effect estimate. Subsequently, this association is extrapolated to the case of zero ME to obtain the corrected estimate. We show that the proposed method fulfils the key property of the SIMEX approach, that is, that the MSE of the generated data will converge to zero if the ME variance converges to zero. Furthermore, the method is applied to real 24HDR data of the I.Family study to correct the effects of salt and alcohol intake on blood pressure. In a simulation study, the method is compared with the NCI method resulting in effect estimates with either smaller MSE or smaller bias in certain situations. In addition, we found our method to be more informative and easier to implement. Therefore, we conclude that the proposed method is useful to promote the dissemination of ME correction methods in nutritional epidemiology.

Original languageEnglish
JournalBiometrical Journal
DOIs
Publication statusAccepted/In press - Jan 1 2019

Fingerprint

Extrapolation
Measurement Error
Simulation
Estimate
Zero
Converge
Measurement Error Model
Box-Cox
Data Modeling
Blood Pressure
Error Correction
Alcohol
Measurement error
Salt
Biased
Simulation Study
Modeling

Keywords

  • 24-hr dietary recall
  • measurement error correction method
  • NCI method
  • non-linear mixed model
  • salt intake

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Statistics and Probability
  • Statistics, Probability and Uncertainty

Cite this

SIMEX for correction of dietary exposure effects with Box-Cox transformed data. / on behalf of the I.Family Consortium.

In: Biometrical Journal, 01.01.2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{47bbb3d8ab694586857d619f7195226f,
title = "SIMEX for correction of dietary exposure effects with Box-Cox transformed data",
abstract = "Modelling dietary data, and especially 24-hr dietary recall (24HDR) data, is a challenge. Ignoring the inherent measurement error (ME) leads to biased effect estimates when the association between an exposure and an outcome is investigated. We propose an adapted simulation extrapolation (SIMEX) algorithm for modelling dietary exposures. For this purpose, we exploit the ME model of the NCI method where we assume the assumption of normally distributed errors of the reported intake on the Box-Cox transformed scale and of unbiased recalls on the original scale. According to the SIMEX algorithm, remeasurements of the observed data with additional ME are generated in order to estimate the association between the level of ME and the resulting effect estimate. Subsequently, this association is extrapolated to the case of zero ME to obtain the corrected estimate. We show that the proposed method fulfils the key property of the SIMEX approach, that is, that the MSE of the generated data will converge to zero if the ME variance converges to zero. Furthermore, the method is applied to real 24HDR data of the I.Family study to correct the effects of salt and alcohol intake on blood pressure. In a simulation study, the method is compared with the NCI method resulting in effect estimates with either smaller MSE or smaller bias in certain situations. In addition, we found our method to be more informative and easier to implement. Therefore, we conclude that the proposed method is useful to promote the dissemination of ME correction methods in nutritional epidemiology.",
keywords = "24-hr dietary recall, measurement error correction method, NCI method, non-linear mixed model, salt intake",
author = "{on behalf of the I.Family Consortium} and Timm Intemann and Kirsten Mehlig and {De Henauw}, Stefaan and Alfonso Siani and Tassos Constantinou and Moreno, {Luis A.} and D{\'e}nes Moln{\'a}r and Toomas Veidebaum and Iris Pigeot",
year = "2019",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1002/bimj.201900066",
language = "English",
journal = "Biometrical Journal",
issn = "0323-3847",
publisher = "Wiley-VCH Verlag",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - SIMEX for correction of dietary exposure effects with Box-Cox transformed data

AU - on behalf of the I.Family Consortium

AU - Intemann, Timm

AU - Mehlig, Kirsten

AU - De Henauw, Stefaan

AU - Siani, Alfonso

AU - Constantinou, Tassos

AU - Moreno, Luis A.

AU - Molnár, Dénes

AU - Veidebaum, Toomas

AU - Pigeot, Iris

PY - 2019/1/1

Y1 - 2019/1/1

N2 - Modelling dietary data, and especially 24-hr dietary recall (24HDR) data, is a challenge. Ignoring the inherent measurement error (ME) leads to biased effect estimates when the association between an exposure and an outcome is investigated. We propose an adapted simulation extrapolation (SIMEX) algorithm for modelling dietary exposures. For this purpose, we exploit the ME model of the NCI method where we assume the assumption of normally distributed errors of the reported intake on the Box-Cox transformed scale and of unbiased recalls on the original scale. According to the SIMEX algorithm, remeasurements of the observed data with additional ME are generated in order to estimate the association between the level of ME and the resulting effect estimate. Subsequently, this association is extrapolated to the case of zero ME to obtain the corrected estimate. We show that the proposed method fulfils the key property of the SIMEX approach, that is, that the MSE of the generated data will converge to zero if the ME variance converges to zero. Furthermore, the method is applied to real 24HDR data of the I.Family study to correct the effects of salt and alcohol intake on blood pressure. In a simulation study, the method is compared with the NCI method resulting in effect estimates with either smaller MSE or smaller bias in certain situations. In addition, we found our method to be more informative and easier to implement. Therefore, we conclude that the proposed method is useful to promote the dissemination of ME correction methods in nutritional epidemiology.

AB - Modelling dietary data, and especially 24-hr dietary recall (24HDR) data, is a challenge. Ignoring the inherent measurement error (ME) leads to biased effect estimates when the association between an exposure and an outcome is investigated. We propose an adapted simulation extrapolation (SIMEX) algorithm for modelling dietary exposures. For this purpose, we exploit the ME model of the NCI method where we assume the assumption of normally distributed errors of the reported intake on the Box-Cox transformed scale and of unbiased recalls on the original scale. According to the SIMEX algorithm, remeasurements of the observed data with additional ME are generated in order to estimate the association between the level of ME and the resulting effect estimate. Subsequently, this association is extrapolated to the case of zero ME to obtain the corrected estimate. We show that the proposed method fulfils the key property of the SIMEX approach, that is, that the MSE of the generated data will converge to zero if the ME variance converges to zero. Furthermore, the method is applied to real 24HDR data of the I.Family study to correct the effects of salt and alcohol intake on blood pressure. In a simulation study, the method is compared with the NCI method resulting in effect estimates with either smaller MSE or smaller bias in certain situations. In addition, we found our method to be more informative and easier to implement. Therefore, we conclude that the proposed method is useful to promote the dissemination of ME correction methods in nutritional epidemiology.

KW - 24-hr dietary recall

KW - measurement error correction method

KW - NCI method

KW - non-linear mixed model

KW - salt intake

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85074854177&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85074854177&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1002/bimj.201900066

DO - 10.1002/bimj.201900066

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85074854177

JO - Biometrical Journal

JF - Biometrical Journal

SN - 0323-3847

ER -