Partitioning European grassland net ecosystem CO2 exchange into gross primary productivity and ecosystem respiration using light response function analysis

T. G. Gilmanov, J. F. Soussana, L. Aires, V. Allard, C. Ammann, M. Balzarolo, Z. Barcza, C. Bernhofer, C. L. Campbell, A. Cernusca, A. Cescatti, J. Clifton-Brown, B. O M Dirks, S. Dore, W. Eugster, J. Fuhrer, C. Gimeno, T. Gruenwald, L. Haszpra, A. HensenA. Ibrom, A. F G Jacobs, M. B. Jones, G. Lanigan, T. Laurila, A. Lohila, G.Manca, B. Marcolla, Z. Nagy, K. Pilegaard, K. Pinter, C. Pio, A. Raschi, N. Rogiers, M. J. Sanz, P. Stefani, M. Sutton, Z. Tuba, R. Valentini, M. L. Williams, G. Wohlfahrt

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

236 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Tower CO2 flux measurements from 20 European grasslands in the EUROGRASSFLUX data set covering a wide range of environmental and management conditions were analyzed with respect to their ecophysiological characteristics and CO2 exchange (gross primary production, Pg, and ecosystem respiration, Re) using light-response function analysis. Photosynthetically active radiation (Q) and top-soil temperature (Ts) were identified as key factors controlling CO2 exchange between grasslands and the atmosphere at the 30-min scale. A nonrectangular hyperbolic light-response model P(Q) and modified nonrectangular hyperbolic light-temperature-response model P(Q, Ts) proved to be flexible tools for modeling CO2 exchange in the light. At night, it was not possible to establish robust instantaneous relationships between CO2 evolution rate rn and environmental drivers, though under certain conditions, a significant relationship rn = r0 ekT Ts was found using observation windows 7-14 days wide. Principal light-response parameters-apparent quantum yield, saturated gross photosynthesis, daytime ecosystem respiration, and gross ecological light-use efficiency, ε = Pg/Q, display patterns of seasonal dynamics which can be formalized and used for modeling. Maximums of these parameters were found in intensively managed grasslands of Atlantic climate. Extensively used semi-natural grasslands of southern and central Europe have much lower production, respiration, and light-use efficiency, while temperate and mountain grasslands of central Europe ranged between these two extremes. Parameters from light-temperature-response analysis of tower data are in agreement with values obtained using closed chambers and free-air CO2 enrichment. Correlations between light-response and productivity parameters provides the possibility to use the easier to measure parameters to estimate the parameters that are more difficult to measure. Gross primary production (Pg) of European grasslands ranges from 1700 g CO2 m-2 year-1 in dry semi-natural pastures to 6900 g CO2 m-2 year-1 in intensively managed Atlantic grasslands. Ecosystem respiration (Re) is in the range 1800 <Re <6000 g CO2 m-2 year-1. Annual net ecosystem CO2 exchange (NEE) varies from significant net uptake (>2400 g CO2 m-2 year-1) to significant release (2 m-2 year-1), though in 15 out of 19 cases grasslands performed as net CO2 sinks. The carbon source was associated with organic rich soils, grazing, and heat stress. Comparison of Pg, Re, and NEE for tower sites with the same characteristics from previously published papers obtained with other methods did not reveal significant discrepancies. Preliminary results indicate relationships of grassland Pg and Re to macroclimatic factors (precipitation and temperature), but these relationships cannot be reduced to simple monofactorial models.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)93-120
Number of pages28
JournalAgriculture, Ecosystems and Environment
Volume121
Issue number1-2
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jun 2007

Fingerprint

ecosystem respiration
primary productivity
respiration
partitioning
grasslands
grassland
carbon dioxide
productivity
ecosystems
ecosystem
cell respiration
topsoil
soil temperature
light use efficiency
Central European region
primary production
analysis
temperature
response analysis
Southern European region

Keywords

  • Ecosystem respiration
  • Eddy covariance-measured CO flux
  • Grassland ecosystems
  • Gross primary production
  • Net CO flux partitioning
  • Nonrectangular hyperbolic model

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Agronomy and Crop Science
  • Ecology, Evolution, Behavior and Systematics
  • Ecology

Cite this

Partitioning European grassland net ecosystem CO2 exchange into gross primary productivity and ecosystem respiration using light response function analysis. / Gilmanov, T. G.; Soussana, J. F.; Aires, L.; Allard, V.; Ammann, C.; Balzarolo, M.; Barcza, Z.; Bernhofer, C.; Campbell, C. L.; Cernusca, A.; Cescatti, A.; Clifton-Brown, J.; Dirks, B. O M; Dore, S.; Eugster, W.; Fuhrer, J.; Gimeno, C.; Gruenwald, T.; Haszpra, L.; Hensen, A.; Ibrom, A.; Jacobs, A. F G; Jones, M. B.; Lanigan, G.; Laurila, T.; Lohila, A.; G.Manca; Marcolla, B.; Nagy, Z.; Pilegaard, K.; Pinter, K.; Pio, C.; Raschi, A.; Rogiers, N.; Sanz, M. J.; Stefani, P.; Sutton, M.; Tuba, Z.; Valentini, R.; Williams, M. L.; Wohlfahrt, G.

In: Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment, Vol. 121, No. 1-2, 06.2007, p. 93-120.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Gilmanov, TG, Soussana, JF, Aires, L, Allard, V, Ammann, C, Balzarolo, M, Barcza, Z, Bernhofer, C, Campbell, CL, Cernusca, A, Cescatti, A, Clifton-Brown, J, Dirks, BOM, Dore, S, Eugster, W, Fuhrer, J, Gimeno, C, Gruenwald, T, Haszpra, L, Hensen, A, Ibrom, A, Jacobs, AFG, Jones, MB, Lanigan, G, Laurila, T, Lohila, A, G.Manca, Marcolla, B, Nagy, Z, Pilegaard, K, Pinter, K, Pio, C, Raschi, A, Rogiers, N, Sanz, MJ, Stefani, P, Sutton, M, Tuba, Z, Valentini, R, Williams, ML & Wohlfahrt, G 2007, 'Partitioning European grassland net ecosystem CO2 exchange into gross primary productivity and ecosystem respiration using light response function analysis', Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment, vol. 121, no. 1-2, pp. 93-120. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.agee.2006.12.008
Gilmanov, T. G. ; Soussana, J. F. ; Aires, L. ; Allard, V. ; Ammann, C. ; Balzarolo, M. ; Barcza, Z. ; Bernhofer, C. ; Campbell, C. L. ; Cernusca, A. ; Cescatti, A. ; Clifton-Brown, J. ; Dirks, B. O M ; Dore, S. ; Eugster, W. ; Fuhrer, J. ; Gimeno, C. ; Gruenwald, T. ; Haszpra, L. ; Hensen, A. ; Ibrom, A. ; Jacobs, A. F G ; Jones, M. B. ; Lanigan, G. ; Laurila, T. ; Lohila, A. ; G.Manca ; Marcolla, B. ; Nagy, Z. ; Pilegaard, K. ; Pinter, K. ; Pio, C. ; Raschi, A. ; Rogiers, N. ; Sanz, M. J. ; Stefani, P. ; Sutton, M. ; Tuba, Z. ; Valentini, R. ; Williams, M. L. ; Wohlfahrt, G. / Partitioning European grassland net ecosystem CO2 exchange into gross primary productivity and ecosystem respiration using light response function analysis. In: Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment. 2007 ; Vol. 121, No. 1-2. pp. 93-120.
@article{3bf076ded70449b6a77445f76547dba9,
title = "Partitioning European grassland net ecosystem CO2 exchange into gross primary productivity and ecosystem respiration using light response function analysis",
abstract = "Tower CO2 flux measurements from 20 European grasslands in the EUROGRASSFLUX data set covering a wide range of environmental and management conditions were analyzed with respect to their ecophysiological characteristics and CO2 exchange (gross primary production, Pg, and ecosystem respiration, Re) using light-response function analysis. Photosynthetically active radiation (Q) and top-soil temperature (Ts) were identified as key factors controlling CO2 exchange between grasslands and the atmosphere at the 30-min scale. A nonrectangular hyperbolic light-response model P(Q) and modified nonrectangular hyperbolic light-temperature-response model P(Q, Ts) proved to be flexible tools for modeling CO2 exchange in the light. At night, it was not possible to establish robust instantaneous relationships between CO2 evolution rate rn and environmental drivers, though under certain conditions, a significant relationship rn = r0 ekT Ts was found using observation windows 7-14 days wide. Principal light-response parameters-apparent quantum yield, saturated gross photosynthesis, daytime ecosystem respiration, and gross ecological light-use efficiency, ε = Pg/Q, display patterns of seasonal dynamics which can be formalized and used for modeling. Maximums of these parameters were found in intensively managed grasslands of Atlantic climate. Extensively used semi-natural grasslands of southern and central Europe have much lower production, respiration, and light-use efficiency, while temperate and mountain grasslands of central Europe ranged between these two extremes. Parameters from light-temperature-response analysis of tower data are in agreement with values obtained using closed chambers and free-air CO2 enrichment. Correlations between light-response and productivity parameters provides the possibility to use the easier to measure parameters to estimate the parameters that are more difficult to measure. Gross primary production (Pg) of European grasslands ranges from 1700 g CO2 m-2 year-1 in dry semi-natural pastures to 6900 g CO2 m-2 year-1 in intensively managed Atlantic grasslands. Ecosystem respiration (Re) is in the range 1800 <Re <6000 g CO2 m-2 year-1. Annual net ecosystem CO2 exchange (NEE) varies from significant net uptake (>2400 g CO2 m-2 year-1) to significant release (2 m-2 year-1), though in 15 out of 19 cases grasslands performed as net CO2 sinks. The carbon source was associated with organic rich soils, grazing, and heat stress. Comparison of Pg, Re, and NEE for tower sites with the same characteristics from previously published papers obtained with other methods did not reveal significant discrepancies. Preliminary results indicate relationships of grassland Pg and Re to macroclimatic factors (precipitation and temperature), but these relationships cannot be reduced to simple monofactorial models.",
keywords = "Ecosystem respiration, Eddy covariance-measured CO flux, Grassland ecosystems, Gross primary production, Net CO flux partitioning, Nonrectangular hyperbolic model",
author = "Gilmanov, {T. G.} and Soussana, {J. F.} and L. Aires and V. Allard and C. Ammann and M. Balzarolo and Z. Barcza and C. Bernhofer and Campbell, {C. L.} and A. Cernusca and A. Cescatti and J. Clifton-Brown and Dirks, {B. O M} and S. Dore and W. Eugster and J. Fuhrer and C. Gimeno and T. Gruenwald and L. Haszpra and A. Hensen and A. Ibrom and Jacobs, {A. F G} and Jones, {M. B.} and G. Lanigan and T. Laurila and A. Lohila and G.Manca and B. Marcolla and Z. Nagy and K. Pilegaard and K. Pinter and C. Pio and A. Raschi and N. Rogiers and Sanz, {M. J.} and P. Stefani and M. Sutton and Z. Tuba and R. Valentini and Williams, {M. L.} and G. Wohlfahrt",
year = "2007",
month = "6",
doi = "10.1016/j.agee.2006.12.008",
language = "English",
volume = "121",
pages = "93--120",
journal = "Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment",
issn = "0167-8809",
publisher = "Elsevier",
number = "1-2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Partitioning European grassland net ecosystem CO2 exchange into gross primary productivity and ecosystem respiration using light response function analysis

AU - Gilmanov, T. G.

AU - Soussana, J. F.

AU - Aires, L.

AU - Allard, V.

AU - Ammann, C.

AU - Balzarolo, M.

AU - Barcza, Z.

AU - Bernhofer, C.

AU - Campbell, C. L.

AU - Cernusca, A.

AU - Cescatti, A.

AU - Clifton-Brown, J.

AU - Dirks, B. O M

AU - Dore, S.

AU - Eugster, W.

AU - Fuhrer, J.

AU - Gimeno, C.

AU - Gruenwald, T.

AU - Haszpra, L.

AU - Hensen, A.

AU - Ibrom, A.

AU - Jacobs, A. F G

AU - Jones, M. B.

AU - Lanigan, G.

AU - Laurila, T.

AU - Lohila, A.

AU - G.Manca,

AU - Marcolla, B.

AU - Nagy, Z.

AU - Pilegaard, K.

AU - Pinter, K.

AU - Pio, C.

AU - Raschi, A.

AU - Rogiers, N.

AU - Sanz, M. J.

AU - Stefani, P.

AU - Sutton, M.

AU - Tuba, Z.

AU - Valentini, R.

AU - Williams, M. L.

AU - Wohlfahrt, G.

PY - 2007/6

Y1 - 2007/6

N2 - Tower CO2 flux measurements from 20 European grasslands in the EUROGRASSFLUX data set covering a wide range of environmental and management conditions were analyzed with respect to their ecophysiological characteristics and CO2 exchange (gross primary production, Pg, and ecosystem respiration, Re) using light-response function analysis. Photosynthetically active radiation (Q) and top-soil temperature (Ts) were identified as key factors controlling CO2 exchange between grasslands and the atmosphere at the 30-min scale. A nonrectangular hyperbolic light-response model P(Q) and modified nonrectangular hyperbolic light-temperature-response model P(Q, Ts) proved to be flexible tools for modeling CO2 exchange in the light. At night, it was not possible to establish robust instantaneous relationships between CO2 evolution rate rn and environmental drivers, though under certain conditions, a significant relationship rn = r0 ekT Ts was found using observation windows 7-14 days wide. Principal light-response parameters-apparent quantum yield, saturated gross photosynthesis, daytime ecosystem respiration, and gross ecological light-use efficiency, ε = Pg/Q, display patterns of seasonal dynamics which can be formalized and used for modeling. Maximums of these parameters were found in intensively managed grasslands of Atlantic climate. Extensively used semi-natural grasslands of southern and central Europe have much lower production, respiration, and light-use efficiency, while temperate and mountain grasslands of central Europe ranged between these two extremes. Parameters from light-temperature-response analysis of tower data are in agreement with values obtained using closed chambers and free-air CO2 enrichment. Correlations between light-response and productivity parameters provides the possibility to use the easier to measure parameters to estimate the parameters that are more difficult to measure. Gross primary production (Pg) of European grasslands ranges from 1700 g CO2 m-2 year-1 in dry semi-natural pastures to 6900 g CO2 m-2 year-1 in intensively managed Atlantic grasslands. Ecosystem respiration (Re) is in the range 1800 <Re <6000 g CO2 m-2 year-1. Annual net ecosystem CO2 exchange (NEE) varies from significant net uptake (>2400 g CO2 m-2 year-1) to significant release (2 m-2 year-1), though in 15 out of 19 cases grasslands performed as net CO2 sinks. The carbon source was associated with organic rich soils, grazing, and heat stress. Comparison of Pg, Re, and NEE for tower sites with the same characteristics from previously published papers obtained with other methods did not reveal significant discrepancies. Preliminary results indicate relationships of grassland Pg and Re to macroclimatic factors (precipitation and temperature), but these relationships cannot be reduced to simple monofactorial models.

AB - Tower CO2 flux measurements from 20 European grasslands in the EUROGRASSFLUX data set covering a wide range of environmental and management conditions were analyzed with respect to their ecophysiological characteristics and CO2 exchange (gross primary production, Pg, and ecosystem respiration, Re) using light-response function analysis. Photosynthetically active radiation (Q) and top-soil temperature (Ts) were identified as key factors controlling CO2 exchange between grasslands and the atmosphere at the 30-min scale. A nonrectangular hyperbolic light-response model P(Q) and modified nonrectangular hyperbolic light-temperature-response model P(Q, Ts) proved to be flexible tools for modeling CO2 exchange in the light. At night, it was not possible to establish robust instantaneous relationships between CO2 evolution rate rn and environmental drivers, though under certain conditions, a significant relationship rn = r0 ekT Ts was found using observation windows 7-14 days wide. Principal light-response parameters-apparent quantum yield, saturated gross photosynthesis, daytime ecosystem respiration, and gross ecological light-use efficiency, ε = Pg/Q, display patterns of seasonal dynamics which can be formalized and used for modeling. Maximums of these parameters were found in intensively managed grasslands of Atlantic climate. Extensively used semi-natural grasslands of southern and central Europe have much lower production, respiration, and light-use efficiency, while temperate and mountain grasslands of central Europe ranged between these two extremes. Parameters from light-temperature-response analysis of tower data are in agreement with values obtained using closed chambers and free-air CO2 enrichment. Correlations between light-response and productivity parameters provides the possibility to use the easier to measure parameters to estimate the parameters that are more difficult to measure. Gross primary production (Pg) of European grasslands ranges from 1700 g CO2 m-2 year-1 in dry semi-natural pastures to 6900 g CO2 m-2 year-1 in intensively managed Atlantic grasslands. Ecosystem respiration (Re) is in the range 1800 <Re <6000 g CO2 m-2 year-1. Annual net ecosystem CO2 exchange (NEE) varies from significant net uptake (>2400 g CO2 m-2 year-1) to significant release (2 m-2 year-1), though in 15 out of 19 cases grasslands performed as net CO2 sinks. The carbon source was associated with organic rich soils, grazing, and heat stress. Comparison of Pg, Re, and NEE for tower sites with the same characteristics from previously published papers obtained with other methods did not reveal significant discrepancies. Preliminary results indicate relationships of grassland Pg and Re to macroclimatic factors (precipitation and temperature), but these relationships cannot be reduced to simple monofactorial models.

KW - Ecosystem respiration

KW - Eddy covariance-measured CO flux

KW - Grassland ecosystems

KW - Gross primary production

KW - Net CO flux partitioning

KW - Nonrectangular hyperbolic model

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=33847308771&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=33847308771&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.agee.2006.12.008

DO - 10.1016/j.agee.2006.12.008

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:33847308771

VL - 121

SP - 93

EP - 120

JO - Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment

JF - Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment

SN - 0167-8809

IS - 1-2

ER -