Laboratory testing of biodegradation in soil: A comparison of chemical and biological methods

Mónika Molnár, Eva Fenyvesi, K. Gruiz, Gábor Illés, Zsuzsanna Nagy, Csilla Hajdu, Plroska Kánnai

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

10 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

An appropriate site characterization performed in a timely and cost-efficient manner is an essential step towards the sustainable remediation of contaminated sites. In the case of soil bioremediation, reliable methods for monitoring and assessing soil microflora and its activity, and microcosms testing site-specific biodegradation of pollutants, are a prerequisite for successful technology selection and planning. The aims of this research were: (1) to evaluate several biological soil-testing methods for characterizing the biodegradation processes in soil; (2) to test the usefulness of a chemical method (cyclodextrin extraction) for simulating the biologically available contaminant fraction; and (3) to compare the chemical and biological test methods with each other, in order to find the most appropriate model for testing the biodegradation potential and its enhancement in contaminated soil. Laboratory-scale microcosm experiments on soils spiked with diesel and transformer oil were performed and evaluated, using chemical analyses and biological methods indicating different endpoints of microbial degradation in soil: contaminant decrease; concentration of degrading microbial cells; and aerobic respiration rate by measuring the dehydrogenase enzyme playing a role in respiration or CO2 as an end-product. As a part of the biological methodology, the following biotests were applied: (1) measurement of contaminant-degrading cell concentration using the dilution method, and statistical evaluation by the most probable number method; (2) soil dehydrogenase enzyme activity test; (3) soil respiration test in a 'closed bottle'; and (4) soil respiration test in a self-designed aerated system (dynamic soil reactors). The chemical analytical methods included: (1) organic solvent extraction followed by gravimetry; (2) organic solvent extraction followed by gas chromatography; and (3) extraction by aqueous cyclodextrin solutions followed by gas chromatography. The results of the chemical and biological tests show a better agreement for diesel oil, than for transformer oil, which Is chemically less homogeneous and less biodegradable. The most coherent results were obtained by the aerobic respiration test and by chemical analyses after hydroxypropylbeta-cyclodextrin extraction (HEH). The correlation between these two and all other tests proved that HEH extraction of the soil followed by analyses may yield a chemical method which is able to properly simulate real biodegradation. In the case of both diesel- and transformer-oil, very good correlation was obtained between the results of cyclodextrin extractions and the results of soil respiration in aerated reactors, which is the system that best models the real environment. Our results suggest that cyclodextrin extraction is suitable for the prediction of hydrocarbon degradation in soil.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)495-506
Number of pages12
JournalLand Contamination and Reclamation
Volume17
Issue number3-4
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2009

Fingerprint

biological method
chemical method
Biodegradation
biodegradation
Soils
Testing
Cyclodextrins
soil
soil respiration
diesel
Insulating oil
respiration
pollutant
oil
microcosm
gas chromatography
Solvent extraction
Impurities
Gas chromatography
comparison

Keywords

  • Bioavailability
  • Biodegradation
  • Biological soil testing methods
  • Cyclodextrin
  • Microcosm
  • Soil bioremediation
  • Testing biodegradation

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Geotechnical Engineering and Engineering Geology
  • Water Science and Technology
  • Environmental Science(all)

Cite this

Laboratory testing of biodegradation in soil : A comparison of chemical and biological methods. / Molnár, Mónika; Fenyvesi, Eva; Gruiz, K.; Illés, Gábor; Nagy, Zsuzsanna; Hajdu, Csilla; Kánnai, Plroska.

In: Land Contamination and Reclamation, Vol. 17, No. 3-4, 2009, p. 495-506.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Molnár, Mónika ; Fenyvesi, Eva ; Gruiz, K. ; Illés, Gábor ; Nagy, Zsuzsanna ; Hajdu, Csilla ; Kánnai, Plroska. / Laboratory testing of biodegradation in soil : A comparison of chemical and biological methods. In: Land Contamination and Reclamation. 2009 ; Vol. 17, No. 3-4. pp. 495-506.
@article{30d81a12e9ee4d81a956d54e48ad11e3,
title = "Laboratory testing of biodegradation in soil: A comparison of chemical and biological methods",
abstract = "An appropriate site characterization performed in a timely and cost-efficient manner is an essential step towards the sustainable remediation of contaminated sites. In the case of soil bioremediation, reliable methods for monitoring and assessing soil microflora and its activity, and microcosms testing site-specific biodegradation of pollutants, are a prerequisite for successful technology selection and planning. The aims of this research were: (1) to evaluate several biological soil-testing methods for characterizing the biodegradation processes in soil; (2) to test the usefulness of a chemical method (cyclodextrin extraction) for simulating the biologically available contaminant fraction; and (3) to compare the chemical and biological test methods with each other, in order to find the most appropriate model for testing the biodegradation potential and its enhancement in contaminated soil. Laboratory-scale microcosm experiments on soils spiked with diesel and transformer oil were performed and evaluated, using chemical analyses and biological methods indicating different endpoints of microbial degradation in soil: contaminant decrease; concentration of degrading microbial cells; and aerobic respiration rate by measuring the dehydrogenase enzyme playing a role in respiration or CO2 as an end-product. As a part of the biological methodology, the following biotests were applied: (1) measurement of contaminant-degrading cell concentration using the dilution method, and statistical evaluation by the most probable number method; (2) soil dehydrogenase enzyme activity test; (3) soil respiration test in a 'closed bottle'; and (4) soil respiration test in a self-designed aerated system (dynamic soil reactors). The chemical analytical methods included: (1) organic solvent extraction followed by gravimetry; (2) organic solvent extraction followed by gas chromatography; and (3) extraction by aqueous cyclodextrin solutions followed by gas chromatography. The results of the chemical and biological tests show a better agreement for diesel oil, than for transformer oil, which Is chemically less homogeneous and less biodegradable. The most coherent results were obtained by the aerobic respiration test and by chemical analyses after hydroxypropylbeta-cyclodextrin extraction (HEH). The correlation between these two and all other tests proved that HEH extraction of the soil followed by analyses may yield a chemical method which is able to properly simulate real biodegradation. In the case of both diesel- and transformer-oil, very good correlation was obtained between the results of cyclodextrin extractions and the results of soil respiration in aerated reactors, which is the system that best models the real environment. Our results suggest that cyclodextrin extraction is suitable for the prediction of hydrocarbon degradation in soil.",
keywords = "Bioavailability, Biodegradation, Biological soil testing methods, Cyclodextrin, Microcosm, Soil bioremediation, Testing biodegradation",
author = "M{\'o}nika Moln{\'a}r and Eva Fenyvesi and K. Gruiz and G{\'a}bor Ill{\'e}s and Zsuzsanna Nagy and Csilla Hajdu and Plroska K{\'a}nnai",
year = "2009",
doi = "10.2462/09670513.956",
language = "English",
volume = "17",
pages = "495--506",
journal = "Land Contamination and Reclamation",
issn = "0967-0513",
publisher = "EPP Publications",
number = "3-4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Laboratory testing of biodegradation in soil

T2 - A comparison of chemical and biological methods

AU - Molnár, Mónika

AU - Fenyvesi, Eva

AU - Gruiz, K.

AU - Illés, Gábor

AU - Nagy, Zsuzsanna

AU - Hajdu, Csilla

AU - Kánnai, Plroska

PY - 2009

Y1 - 2009

N2 - An appropriate site characterization performed in a timely and cost-efficient manner is an essential step towards the sustainable remediation of contaminated sites. In the case of soil bioremediation, reliable methods for monitoring and assessing soil microflora and its activity, and microcosms testing site-specific biodegradation of pollutants, are a prerequisite for successful technology selection and planning. The aims of this research were: (1) to evaluate several biological soil-testing methods for characterizing the biodegradation processes in soil; (2) to test the usefulness of a chemical method (cyclodextrin extraction) for simulating the biologically available contaminant fraction; and (3) to compare the chemical and biological test methods with each other, in order to find the most appropriate model for testing the biodegradation potential and its enhancement in contaminated soil. Laboratory-scale microcosm experiments on soils spiked with diesel and transformer oil were performed and evaluated, using chemical analyses and biological methods indicating different endpoints of microbial degradation in soil: contaminant decrease; concentration of degrading microbial cells; and aerobic respiration rate by measuring the dehydrogenase enzyme playing a role in respiration or CO2 as an end-product. As a part of the biological methodology, the following biotests were applied: (1) measurement of contaminant-degrading cell concentration using the dilution method, and statistical evaluation by the most probable number method; (2) soil dehydrogenase enzyme activity test; (3) soil respiration test in a 'closed bottle'; and (4) soil respiration test in a self-designed aerated system (dynamic soil reactors). The chemical analytical methods included: (1) organic solvent extraction followed by gravimetry; (2) organic solvent extraction followed by gas chromatography; and (3) extraction by aqueous cyclodextrin solutions followed by gas chromatography. The results of the chemical and biological tests show a better agreement for diesel oil, than for transformer oil, which Is chemically less homogeneous and less biodegradable. The most coherent results were obtained by the aerobic respiration test and by chemical analyses after hydroxypropylbeta-cyclodextrin extraction (HEH). The correlation between these two and all other tests proved that HEH extraction of the soil followed by analyses may yield a chemical method which is able to properly simulate real biodegradation. In the case of both diesel- and transformer-oil, very good correlation was obtained between the results of cyclodextrin extractions and the results of soil respiration in aerated reactors, which is the system that best models the real environment. Our results suggest that cyclodextrin extraction is suitable for the prediction of hydrocarbon degradation in soil.

AB - An appropriate site characterization performed in a timely and cost-efficient manner is an essential step towards the sustainable remediation of contaminated sites. In the case of soil bioremediation, reliable methods for monitoring and assessing soil microflora and its activity, and microcosms testing site-specific biodegradation of pollutants, are a prerequisite for successful technology selection and planning. The aims of this research were: (1) to evaluate several biological soil-testing methods for characterizing the biodegradation processes in soil; (2) to test the usefulness of a chemical method (cyclodextrin extraction) for simulating the biologically available contaminant fraction; and (3) to compare the chemical and biological test methods with each other, in order to find the most appropriate model for testing the biodegradation potential and its enhancement in contaminated soil. Laboratory-scale microcosm experiments on soils spiked with diesel and transformer oil were performed and evaluated, using chemical analyses and biological methods indicating different endpoints of microbial degradation in soil: contaminant decrease; concentration of degrading microbial cells; and aerobic respiration rate by measuring the dehydrogenase enzyme playing a role in respiration or CO2 as an end-product. As a part of the biological methodology, the following biotests were applied: (1) measurement of contaminant-degrading cell concentration using the dilution method, and statistical evaluation by the most probable number method; (2) soil dehydrogenase enzyme activity test; (3) soil respiration test in a 'closed bottle'; and (4) soil respiration test in a self-designed aerated system (dynamic soil reactors). The chemical analytical methods included: (1) organic solvent extraction followed by gravimetry; (2) organic solvent extraction followed by gas chromatography; and (3) extraction by aqueous cyclodextrin solutions followed by gas chromatography. The results of the chemical and biological tests show a better agreement for diesel oil, than for transformer oil, which Is chemically less homogeneous and less biodegradable. The most coherent results were obtained by the aerobic respiration test and by chemical analyses after hydroxypropylbeta-cyclodextrin extraction (HEH). The correlation between these two and all other tests proved that HEH extraction of the soil followed by analyses may yield a chemical method which is able to properly simulate real biodegradation. In the case of both diesel- and transformer-oil, very good correlation was obtained between the results of cyclodextrin extractions and the results of soil respiration in aerated reactors, which is the system that best models the real environment. Our results suggest that cyclodextrin extraction is suitable for the prediction of hydrocarbon degradation in soil.

KW - Bioavailability

KW - Biodegradation

KW - Biological soil testing methods

KW - Cyclodextrin

KW - Microcosm

KW - Soil bioremediation

KW - Testing biodegradation

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=77955147410&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=77955147410&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.2462/09670513.956

DO - 10.2462/09670513.956

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:77955147410

VL - 17

SP - 495

EP - 506

JO - Land Contamination and Reclamation

JF - Land Contamination and Reclamation

SN - 0967-0513

IS - 3-4

ER -