Electron Density Errors and Density-Driven Exchange-Correlation Energy Errors in Approximate Density Functional Calculations

Pál D. Mezei, G. Csonka, M. Kállay

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

20 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Since its formal introduction, density functional theory has achieved many successes in the fields of molecular and solid-state chemistry. According to its central theorems, the ground state of a many-electron system is fully described by its electron density, and the exact functional minimizes the energy at the exact electron density. For many years of density functional development, it was assumed that the improvements in the energy are accompanied by the improvements in the density, and the approximations approach the exact functional. In a recent analysis (Medvedev et al. Science 2017, 355, 49â52.), it has been pointed out for 14 first row (Be-Ne) atoms and cations with 2, 4, or 10 electrons that the nowadays popular flexible but physically less rigorous approximate density functionals may provide large errors in the calculated electron densities despite the accurate energies. Although far-reaching conclusions have been drawn in this work, the methodology used by the authors may need improvements. Most importantly, their benchmark set was biased toward small atomic cations with compressed, high electron densities. In our paper, we construct a molecular test set with chemically relevant densities and analyze the performance of several density functional approximations including the less-investigated double hybrids. We apply an intensive error measure for the density, its gradient, and its Laplacian and examine how the errors in the density propagate into the semilocal exchange-correlation energy. While we have confirmed the broad conclusions of Medvedev et al., our different way of analyzing the data has led to conclusions that differ in detail. Finally, seeking for a rationale behind the global hybrid or double hybrid methods from the density's point of view, we also analyze the role of the exact exchange and second-order perturbative correlation mixing in PBE-based global hybrid and double hybrid functional forms.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)4753-4764
Number of pages12
JournalJournal of Chemical Theory and Computation
Volume13
Issue number10
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Oct 10 2017

Fingerprint

Density functional theory
Carrier concentration
Cations
Positive ions
energy
Electrons
Ground state
cations
Atoms
approximation
functionals
electrons
theorems
methodology
chemistry
density functional theory
solid state
gradients
ground state
atoms

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Computer Science Applications
  • Physical and Theoretical Chemistry

Cite this

@article{7e5fe2ace4c947f0949c0308eb9bffed,
title = "Electron Density Errors and Density-Driven Exchange-Correlation Energy Errors in Approximate Density Functional Calculations",
abstract = "Since its formal introduction, density functional theory has achieved many successes in the fields of molecular and solid-state chemistry. According to its central theorems, the ground state of a many-electron system is fully described by its electron density, and the exact functional minimizes the energy at the exact electron density. For many years of density functional development, it was assumed that the improvements in the energy are accompanied by the improvements in the density, and the approximations approach the exact functional. In a recent analysis (Medvedev et al. Science 2017, 355, 49{\^a}52.), it has been pointed out for 14 first row (Be-Ne) atoms and cations with 2, 4, or 10 electrons that the nowadays popular flexible but physically less rigorous approximate density functionals may provide large errors in the calculated electron densities despite the accurate energies. Although far-reaching conclusions have been drawn in this work, the methodology used by the authors may need improvements. Most importantly, their benchmark set was biased toward small atomic cations with compressed, high electron densities. In our paper, we construct a molecular test set with chemically relevant densities and analyze the performance of several density functional approximations including the less-investigated double hybrids. We apply an intensive error measure for the density, its gradient, and its Laplacian and examine how the errors in the density propagate into the semilocal exchange-correlation energy. While we have confirmed the broad conclusions of Medvedev et al., our different way of analyzing the data has led to conclusions that differ in detail. Finally, seeking for a rationale behind the global hybrid or double hybrid methods from the density's point of view, we also analyze the role of the exact exchange and second-order perturbative correlation mixing in PBE-based global hybrid and double hybrid functional forms.",
author = "Mezei, {P{\'a}l D.} and G. Csonka and M. K{\'a}llay",
year = "2017",
month = "10",
day = "10",
doi = "10.1021/acs.jctc.7b00550",
language = "English",
volume = "13",
pages = "4753--4764",
journal = "Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation",
issn = "1549-9618",
publisher = "American Chemical Society",
number = "10",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Electron Density Errors and Density-Driven Exchange-Correlation Energy Errors in Approximate Density Functional Calculations

AU - Mezei, Pál D.

AU - Csonka, G.

AU - Kállay, M.

PY - 2017/10/10

Y1 - 2017/10/10

N2 - Since its formal introduction, density functional theory has achieved many successes in the fields of molecular and solid-state chemistry. According to its central theorems, the ground state of a many-electron system is fully described by its electron density, and the exact functional minimizes the energy at the exact electron density. For many years of density functional development, it was assumed that the improvements in the energy are accompanied by the improvements in the density, and the approximations approach the exact functional. In a recent analysis (Medvedev et al. Science 2017, 355, 49â52.), it has been pointed out for 14 first row (Be-Ne) atoms and cations with 2, 4, or 10 electrons that the nowadays popular flexible but physically less rigorous approximate density functionals may provide large errors in the calculated electron densities despite the accurate energies. Although far-reaching conclusions have been drawn in this work, the methodology used by the authors may need improvements. Most importantly, their benchmark set was biased toward small atomic cations with compressed, high electron densities. In our paper, we construct a molecular test set with chemically relevant densities and analyze the performance of several density functional approximations including the less-investigated double hybrids. We apply an intensive error measure for the density, its gradient, and its Laplacian and examine how the errors in the density propagate into the semilocal exchange-correlation energy. While we have confirmed the broad conclusions of Medvedev et al., our different way of analyzing the data has led to conclusions that differ in detail. Finally, seeking for a rationale behind the global hybrid or double hybrid methods from the density's point of view, we also analyze the role of the exact exchange and second-order perturbative correlation mixing in PBE-based global hybrid and double hybrid functional forms.

AB - Since its formal introduction, density functional theory has achieved many successes in the fields of molecular and solid-state chemistry. According to its central theorems, the ground state of a many-electron system is fully described by its electron density, and the exact functional minimizes the energy at the exact electron density. For many years of density functional development, it was assumed that the improvements in the energy are accompanied by the improvements in the density, and the approximations approach the exact functional. In a recent analysis (Medvedev et al. Science 2017, 355, 49â52.), it has been pointed out for 14 first row (Be-Ne) atoms and cations with 2, 4, or 10 electrons that the nowadays popular flexible but physically less rigorous approximate density functionals may provide large errors in the calculated electron densities despite the accurate energies. Although far-reaching conclusions have been drawn in this work, the methodology used by the authors may need improvements. Most importantly, their benchmark set was biased toward small atomic cations with compressed, high electron densities. In our paper, we construct a molecular test set with chemically relevant densities and analyze the performance of several density functional approximations including the less-investigated double hybrids. We apply an intensive error measure for the density, its gradient, and its Laplacian and examine how the errors in the density propagate into the semilocal exchange-correlation energy. While we have confirmed the broad conclusions of Medvedev et al., our different way of analyzing the data has led to conclusions that differ in detail. Finally, seeking for a rationale behind the global hybrid or double hybrid methods from the density's point of view, we also analyze the role of the exact exchange and second-order perturbative correlation mixing in PBE-based global hybrid and double hybrid functional forms.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85031009811&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85031009811&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1021/acs.jctc.7b00550

DO - 10.1021/acs.jctc.7b00550

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85031009811

VL - 13

SP - 4753

EP - 4764

JO - Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation

JF - Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation

SN - 1549-9618

IS - 10

ER -