Drug efficiency indices for improvement of molecular docking scoring functions

Alfonso T. García-Sosa, C. Hetényi, U. K O Maran

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

31 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

A dataset of protein-drug complexes with experimental binding energy and crystal structure were analyzed and the performance of different docking engines and scoring functions (as well as components of these) for predicting the free energy of binding and several ligand efficiency indices were compared. The aim was not to evaluate the best docking method, but to determine the effect of different efficiency indices on the experimental and predicted free energy. Some ligand efficiency indices, such as ΔG/W (Wiener index), ΔG/NoC (number of carbons), and ΔG/P (partition coefficient), improve the correlation between experimental and calculated, values. This effect was shown to be valid across the different scoring functions and docking programs. It also removes the common bias of scoring functions in favor of larger ligands. For all scoring functions, the efficiency indices effectively normalize the free energy derived indices, to give values closer to experiment. Compound collection filtering can be done prior or after docking, using pharmacokinetic as well as pharmacodynamic profiles. Achieving these better correlations with experiment can improve the ability of docking scoring functions to predict active molecules in virtual screening.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)174-184
Number of pages11
JournalJournal of Computational Chemistry
Volume31
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jan 15 2010

Fingerprint

Efficiency Index
Molecular Docking
Docking
Scoring
Drugs
Free energy
Free Energy
Pharmaceutical Preparations
Ligands
Pharmacodynamics
Virtual Screening
Wiener Index
Normalize
Pharmacokinetics
Binding Energy
Crystal Structure
Binding energy
Experiment
Screening
Carbon

Keywords

  • Docking
  • Drug design
  • Free energy of binding
  • Scoring function
  • Virtual screening

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Chemistry(all)
  • Computational Mathematics

Cite this

Drug efficiency indices for improvement of molecular docking scoring functions. / García-Sosa, Alfonso T.; Hetényi, C.; Maran, U. K O.

In: Journal of Computational Chemistry, Vol. 31, No. 1, 15.01.2010, p. 174-184.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

García-Sosa, Alfonso T. ; Hetényi, C. ; Maran, U. K O. / Drug efficiency indices for improvement of molecular docking scoring functions. In: Journal of Computational Chemistry. 2010 ; Vol. 31, No. 1. pp. 174-184.
@article{97e787a25cd84509926e423842f139a9,
title = "Drug efficiency indices for improvement of molecular docking scoring functions",
abstract = "A dataset of protein-drug complexes with experimental binding energy and crystal structure were analyzed and the performance of different docking engines and scoring functions (as well as components of these) for predicting the free energy of binding and several ligand efficiency indices were compared. The aim was not to evaluate the best docking method, but to determine the effect of different efficiency indices on the experimental and predicted free energy. Some ligand efficiency indices, such as ΔG/W (Wiener index), ΔG/NoC (number of carbons), and ΔG/P (partition coefficient), improve the correlation between experimental and calculated, values. This effect was shown to be valid across the different scoring functions and docking programs. It also removes the common bias of scoring functions in favor of larger ligands. For all scoring functions, the efficiency indices effectively normalize the free energy derived indices, to give values closer to experiment. Compound collection filtering can be done prior or after docking, using pharmacokinetic as well as pharmacodynamic profiles. Achieving these better correlations with experiment can improve the ability of docking scoring functions to predict active molecules in virtual screening.",
keywords = "Docking, Drug design, Free energy of binding, Scoring function, Virtual screening",
author = "Garc{\'i}a-Sosa, {Alfonso T.} and C. Het{\'e}nyi and Maran, {U. K O}",
year = "2010",
month = "1",
day = "15",
doi = "10.1002/jcc.21306",
language = "English",
volume = "31",
pages = "174--184",
journal = "Journal of Computational Chemistry",
issn = "0192-8651",
publisher = "John Wiley and Sons Inc.",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Drug efficiency indices for improvement of molecular docking scoring functions

AU - García-Sosa, Alfonso T.

AU - Hetényi, C.

AU - Maran, U. K O

PY - 2010/1/15

Y1 - 2010/1/15

N2 - A dataset of protein-drug complexes with experimental binding energy and crystal structure were analyzed and the performance of different docking engines and scoring functions (as well as components of these) for predicting the free energy of binding and several ligand efficiency indices were compared. The aim was not to evaluate the best docking method, but to determine the effect of different efficiency indices on the experimental and predicted free energy. Some ligand efficiency indices, such as ΔG/W (Wiener index), ΔG/NoC (number of carbons), and ΔG/P (partition coefficient), improve the correlation between experimental and calculated, values. This effect was shown to be valid across the different scoring functions and docking programs. It also removes the common bias of scoring functions in favor of larger ligands. For all scoring functions, the efficiency indices effectively normalize the free energy derived indices, to give values closer to experiment. Compound collection filtering can be done prior or after docking, using pharmacokinetic as well as pharmacodynamic profiles. Achieving these better correlations with experiment can improve the ability of docking scoring functions to predict active molecules in virtual screening.

AB - A dataset of protein-drug complexes with experimental binding energy and crystal structure were analyzed and the performance of different docking engines and scoring functions (as well as components of these) for predicting the free energy of binding and several ligand efficiency indices were compared. The aim was not to evaluate the best docking method, but to determine the effect of different efficiency indices on the experimental and predicted free energy. Some ligand efficiency indices, such as ΔG/W (Wiener index), ΔG/NoC (number of carbons), and ΔG/P (partition coefficient), improve the correlation between experimental and calculated, values. This effect was shown to be valid across the different scoring functions and docking programs. It also removes the common bias of scoring functions in favor of larger ligands. For all scoring functions, the efficiency indices effectively normalize the free energy derived indices, to give values closer to experiment. Compound collection filtering can be done prior or after docking, using pharmacokinetic as well as pharmacodynamic profiles. Achieving these better correlations with experiment can improve the ability of docking scoring functions to predict active molecules in virtual screening.

KW - Docking

KW - Drug design

KW - Free energy of binding

KW - Scoring function

KW - Virtual screening

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=72449144245&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=72449144245&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1002/jcc.21306

DO - 10.1002/jcc.21306

M3 - Article

VL - 31

SP - 174

EP - 184

JO - Journal of Computational Chemistry

JF - Journal of Computational Chemistry

SN - 0192-8651

IS - 1

ER -