Does Innovation Success Influence Social Interactions? An Experimental Test in House Sparrows

Bálint Preiszner, Sándor Papp, Erno Vincze, V. Bókony, A. Likér

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

4 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

In group-living animals, individuals may benefit from the presence of an innovative group-mate because new resources made available by innovators can be exploited, for example by scrounging or social learning. As a consequence, it may pay off to take the group-mates' problem-solving abilities into account in social interactions such as aggression or spatial association, for example because dominance over an innovative group-mate can increase scrounging success, while spatial proximity may increase the chance of both direct exploitation and social learning. In this study, we tested whether the individuals' innovation success influences their social interactions with group-mates in small captive flocks of house sparrows (Passer domesticus). First, we measured the birds' actual problem-solving success in individual food-extracting tasks. Then, we manipulated their apparent problem-solving success in one task (by allowing or not allowing them to open a feeder repeatedly) while a new, unfamiliar group-member (focal individual) had the opportunity to witness their performance. After this manipulation, we observed the frequency and intensity of aggression and the frequency of spatial associations between the focal individuals and their manipulated flock-mates. Although flock-mates behaved according to their treatments during manipulations, their apparent problem-solving success did not affect significantly the focal individuals' agonistic behaviour or spatial associations. These results do not support that sparrows take flock-mates' problem-solving abilities into account during social interactions. However, focal individuals attacked those flock-mates more frequently that had higher actual problem-solving success (not witnessed directly by the focal individuals), although aggression intensity and spatial association by the focal birds were unrelated to the flock-mates' actual success. If this association between flock-mates' actual innovativeness and focal individuals' aggression is not due to confounding effects, it may imply that house sparrows can use more subtle cues to assess the group-mates' problem-solving ability than direct observation of their performance in simple foraging tasks.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)661-673
Number of pages13
JournalEthology
Volume121
Issue number7
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jul 1 2015

Fingerprint

Passer domesticus
aggression
flocks
innovation
learning
testing
bird
agonistic behavior
Passeriformes
birds
food
test
animal
resource
foraging

Keywords

  • Aggressive interactions
  • Group living
  • Problem-solving
  • Social success
  • Spatial association

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Animal Science and Zoology
  • Ecology, Evolution, Behavior and Systematics

Cite this

Does Innovation Success Influence Social Interactions? An Experimental Test in House Sparrows. / Preiszner, Bálint; Papp, Sándor; Vincze, Erno; Bókony, V.; Likér, A.

In: Ethology, Vol. 121, No. 7, 01.07.2015, p. 661-673.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Preiszner, Bálint ; Papp, Sándor ; Vincze, Erno ; Bókony, V. ; Likér, A. / Does Innovation Success Influence Social Interactions? An Experimental Test in House Sparrows. In: Ethology. 2015 ; Vol. 121, No. 7. pp. 661-673.
@article{18911ea069744b1190ea62b336bf7e90,
title = "Does Innovation Success Influence Social Interactions? An Experimental Test in House Sparrows",
abstract = "In group-living animals, individuals may benefit from the presence of an innovative group-mate because new resources made available by innovators can be exploited, for example by scrounging or social learning. As a consequence, it may pay off to take the group-mates' problem-solving abilities into account in social interactions such as aggression or spatial association, for example because dominance over an innovative group-mate can increase scrounging success, while spatial proximity may increase the chance of both direct exploitation and social learning. In this study, we tested whether the individuals' innovation success influences their social interactions with group-mates in small captive flocks of house sparrows (Passer domesticus). First, we measured the birds' actual problem-solving success in individual food-extracting tasks. Then, we manipulated their apparent problem-solving success in one task (by allowing or not allowing them to open a feeder repeatedly) while a new, unfamiliar group-member (focal individual) had the opportunity to witness their performance. After this manipulation, we observed the frequency and intensity of aggression and the frequency of spatial associations between the focal individuals and their manipulated flock-mates. Although flock-mates behaved according to their treatments during manipulations, their apparent problem-solving success did not affect significantly the focal individuals' agonistic behaviour or spatial associations. These results do not support that sparrows take flock-mates' problem-solving abilities into account during social interactions. However, focal individuals attacked those flock-mates more frequently that had higher actual problem-solving success (not witnessed directly by the focal individuals), although aggression intensity and spatial association by the focal birds were unrelated to the flock-mates' actual success. If this association between flock-mates' actual innovativeness and focal individuals' aggression is not due to confounding effects, it may imply that house sparrows can use more subtle cues to assess the group-mates' problem-solving ability than direct observation of their performance in simple foraging tasks.",
keywords = "Aggressive interactions, Group living, Problem-solving, Social success, Spatial association",
author = "B{\'a}lint Preiszner and S{\'a}ndor Papp and Erno Vincze and V. B{\'o}kony and A. Lik{\'e}r",
year = "2015",
month = "7",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1111/eth.12380",
language = "English",
volume = "121",
pages = "661--673",
journal = "Ethology",
issn = "0179-1613",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "7",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Does Innovation Success Influence Social Interactions? An Experimental Test in House Sparrows

AU - Preiszner, Bálint

AU - Papp, Sándor

AU - Vincze, Erno

AU - Bókony, V.

AU - Likér, A.

PY - 2015/7/1

Y1 - 2015/7/1

N2 - In group-living animals, individuals may benefit from the presence of an innovative group-mate because new resources made available by innovators can be exploited, for example by scrounging or social learning. As a consequence, it may pay off to take the group-mates' problem-solving abilities into account in social interactions such as aggression or spatial association, for example because dominance over an innovative group-mate can increase scrounging success, while spatial proximity may increase the chance of both direct exploitation and social learning. In this study, we tested whether the individuals' innovation success influences their social interactions with group-mates in small captive flocks of house sparrows (Passer domesticus). First, we measured the birds' actual problem-solving success in individual food-extracting tasks. Then, we manipulated their apparent problem-solving success in one task (by allowing or not allowing them to open a feeder repeatedly) while a new, unfamiliar group-member (focal individual) had the opportunity to witness their performance. After this manipulation, we observed the frequency and intensity of aggression and the frequency of spatial associations between the focal individuals and their manipulated flock-mates. Although flock-mates behaved according to their treatments during manipulations, their apparent problem-solving success did not affect significantly the focal individuals' agonistic behaviour or spatial associations. These results do not support that sparrows take flock-mates' problem-solving abilities into account during social interactions. However, focal individuals attacked those flock-mates more frequently that had higher actual problem-solving success (not witnessed directly by the focal individuals), although aggression intensity and spatial association by the focal birds were unrelated to the flock-mates' actual success. If this association between flock-mates' actual innovativeness and focal individuals' aggression is not due to confounding effects, it may imply that house sparrows can use more subtle cues to assess the group-mates' problem-solving ability than direct observation of their performance in simple foraging tasks.

AB - In group-living animals, individuals may benefit from the presence of an innovative group-mate because new resources made available by innovators can be exploited, for example by scrounging or social learning. As a consequence, it may pay off to take the group-mates' problem-solving abilities into account in social interactions such as aggression or spatial association, for example because dominance over an innovative group-mate can increase scrounging success, while spatial proximity may increase the chance of both direct exploitation and social learning. In this study, we tested whether the individuals' innovation success influences their social interactions with group-mates in small captive flocks of house sparrows (Passer domesticus). First, we measured the birds' actual problem-solving success in individual food-extracting tasks. Then, we manipulated their apparent problem-solving success in one task (by allowing or not allowing them to open a feeder repeatedly) while a new, unfamiliar group-member (focal individual) had the opportunity to witness their performance. After this manipulation, we observed the frequency and intensity of aggression and the frequency of spatial associations between the focal individuals and their manipulated flock-mates. Although flock-mates behaved according to their treatments during manipulations, their apparent problem-solving success did not affect significantly the focal individuals' agonistic behaviour or spatial associations. These results do not support that sparrows take flock-mates' problem-solving abilities into account during social interactions. However, focal individuals attacked those flock-mates more frequently that had higher actual problem-solving success (not witnessed directly by the focal individuals), although aggression intensity and spatial association by the focal birds were unrelated to the flock-mates' actual success. If this association between flock-mates' actual innovativeness and focal individuals' aggression is not due to confounding effects, it may imply that house sparrows can use more subtle cues to assess the group-mates' problem-solving ability than direct observation of their performance in simple foraging tasks.

KW - Aggressive interactions

KW - Group living

KW - Problem-solving

KW - Social success

KW - Spatial association

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84930413089&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84930413089&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1111/eth.12380

DO - 10.1111/eth.12380

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:84930413089

VL - 121

SP - 661

EP - 673

JO - Ethology

JF - Ethology

SN - 0179-1613

IS - 7

ER -