Computational study of reactivity and transition structures in nucleophilic substitutions on benzyl bromides

Ferenc Ruff, Ödön Farkas, Árpád Kucsman

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

16 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

DFT computations on the mechanisms of nucleophilic substitutions on benzyl bromides were performed and the calculated activation parameters were compared with experimentally acquired data. In vacuo, the presence of electron-withdrawing (e-w) groups on the benzyl bromides accelerated the reactions and the calculated ΔG‡/ΔH‡/ΔS‡ vs. σ plots were linear, while in solvents there were breaks in the calculated and measured ΔG‡/ΔH‡ vs. σ+ plots of the reactions between the benzyl bromides and Br-, both with electron-donating (e-d) and with e-w substituents accelerating the reactions. The calculated ΔS‡ values appeared to be independent of the substituents. In solvents, the calculated ΔG‡/ΔH‡/ΔS‡ vs. σ+ plots for the reactions between benzyl bromides and pyridine were linear, whereas breaks were observed in the plots of the measured data. These reactions were promoted by e-d substituents, but the measured reactivities of substrates bearing e-w groups were higher than expected. No breaks in the ΔG‡/ΔH‡/ΔS‡ vs. σ plots were observed when the substituents on the pyridine nucleophile were changed. The best agreement between the calculated and measured values was obtained for the least solvent-dependent ΔG‡ parameter. The experimentally measured ΔS‡ and ΔH‡ data were influenced by the rearrangement of the solvent mole-cules. The calculated structural parameters of the transition states (TSs) varied linearly with the substituent constants, with loose and tight distorted trigonal-bipyramidal TSs being formed by benzyl bromides bearing e-d and e-w groups, respectively. The reactions proceeded by SN2 mechanisms; only the transition structures were changed with the substituents and the media.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)5570-5580
Number of pages11
JournalEuropean Journal of Organic Chemistry
Issue number24
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Dec 11 2006

Fingerprint

Substitution reactions
Electrons
Bearings (structural)
Nucleophiles
benzyl bromide
Discrete Fourier transforms
Chemical activation
Substrates
pyridine

Keywords

  • Activation parameters
  • Benzyl bromides
  • Density functional calculations
  • Nucleophilic substitutions
  • Solvent effect
  • Substituent effect

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Organic Chemistry

Cite this

Computational study of reactivity and transition structures in nucleophilic substitutions on benzyl bromides. / Ruff, Ferenc; Farkas, Ödön; Kucsman, Árpád.

In: European Journal of Organic Chemistry, No. 24, 11.12.2006, p. 5570-5580.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{edde297fc0e14e89bdafe67bda24b865,
title = "Computational study of reactivity and transition structures in nucleophilic substitutions on benzyl bromides",
abstract = "DFT computations on the mechanisms of nucleophilic substitutions on benzyl bromides were performed and the calculated activation parameters were compared with experimentally acquired data. In vacuo, the presence of electron-withdrawing (e-w) groups on the benzyl bromides accelerated the reactions and the calculated ΔG‡/ΔH‡/ΔS‡ vs. σ plots were linear, while in solvents there were breaks in the calculated and measured ΔG‡/ΔH‡ vs. σ+ plots of the reactions between the benzyl bromides and Br-, both with electron-donating (e-d) and with e-w substituents accelerating the reactions. The calculated ΔS‡ values appeared to be independent of the substituents. In solvents, the calculated ΔG‡/ΔH‡/ΔS‡ vs. σ+ plots for the reactions between benzyl bromides and pyridine were linear, whereas breaks were observed in the plots of the measured data. These reactions were promoted by e-d substituents, but the measured reactivities of substrates bearing e-w groups were higher than expected. No breaks in the ΔG‡/ΔH‡/ΔS‡ vs. σ plots were observed when the substituents on the pyridine nucleophile were changed. The best agreement between the calculated and measured values was obtained for the least solvent-dependent ΔG‡ parameter. The experimentally measured ΔS‡ and ΔH‡ data were influenced by the rearrangement of the solvent mole-cules. The calculated structural parameters of the transition states (TSs) varied linearly with the substituent constants, with loose and tight distorted trigonal-bipyramidal TSs being formed by benzyl bromides bearing e-d and e-w groups, respectively. The reactions proceeded by SN2 mechanisms; only the transition structures were changed with the substituents and the media.",
keywords = "Activation parameters, Benzyl bromides, Density functional calculations, Nucleophilic substitutions, Solvent effect, Substituent effect",
author = "Ferenc Ruff and {\"O}d{\"o}n Farkas and {\'A}rp{\'a}d Kucsman",
year = "2006",
month = "12",
day = "11",
doi = "10.1002/ejoc.200600543",
language = "English",
pages = "5570--5580",
journal = "LIEBIGS ANN. CHEM.",
issn = "1434-193X",
publisher = "Wiley-VCH Verlag",
number = "24",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Computational study of reactivity and transition structures in nucleophilic substitutions on benzyl bromides

AU - Ruff, Ferenc

AU - Farkas, Ödön

AU - Kucsman, Árpád

PY - 2006/12/11

Y1 - 2006/12/11

N2 - DFT computations on the mechanisms of nucleophilic substitutions on benzyl bromides were performed and the calculated activation parameters were compared with experimentally acquired data. In vacuo, the presence of electron-withdrawing (e-w) groups on the benzyl bromides accelerated the reactions and the calculated ΔG‡/ΔH‡/ΔS‡ vs. σ plots were linear, while in solvents there were breaks in the calculated and measured ΔG‡/ΔH‡ vs. σ+ plots of the reactions between the benzyl bromides and Br-, both with electron-donating (e-d) and with e-w substituents accelerating the reactions. The calculated ΔS‡ values appeared to be independent of the substituents. In solvents, the calculated ΔG‡/ΔH‡/ΔS‡ vs. σ+ plots for the reactions between benzyl bromides and pyridine were linear, whereas breaks were observed in the plots of the measured data. These reactions were promoted by e-d substituents, but the measured reactivities of substrates bearing e-w groups were higher than expected. No breaks in the ΔG‡/ΔH‡/ΔS‡ vs. σ plots were observed when the substituents on the pyridine nucleophile were changed. The best agreement between the calculated and measured values was obtained for the least solvent-dependent ΔG‡ parameter. The experimentally measured ΔS‡ and ΔH‡ data were influenced by the rearrangement of the solvent mole-cules. The calculated structural parameters of the transition states (TSs) varied linearly with the substituent constants, with loose and tight distorted trigonal-bipyramidal TSs being formed by benzyl bromides bearing e-d and e-w groups, respectively. The reactions proceeded by SN2 mechanisms; only the transition structures were changed with the substituents and the media.

AB - DFT computations on the mechanisms of nucleophilic substitutions on benzyl bromides were performed and the calculated activation parameters were compared with experimentally acquired data. In vacuo, the presence of electron-withdrawing (e-w) groups on the benzyl bromides accelerated the reactions and the calculated ΔG‡/ΔH‡/ΔS‡ vs. σ plots were linear, while in solvents there were breaks in the calculated and measured ΔG‡/ΔH‡ vs. σ+ plots of the reactions between the benzyl bromides and Br-, both with electron-donating (e-d) and with e-w substituents accelerating the reactions. The calculated ΔS‡ values appeared to be independent of the substituents. In solvents, the calculated ΔG‡/ΔH‡/ΔS‡ vs. σ+ plots for the reactions between benzyl bromides and pyridine were linear, whereas breaks were observed in the plots of the measured data. These reactions were promoted by e-d substituents, but the measured reactivities of substrates bearing e-w groups were higher than expected. No breaks in the ΔG‡/ΔH‡/ΔS‡ vs. σ plots were observed when the substituents on the pyridine nucleophile were changed. The best agreement between the calculated and measured values was obtained for the least solvent-dependent ΔG‡ parameter. The experimentally measured ΔS‡ and ΔH‡ data were influenced by the rearrangement of the solvent mole-cules. The calculated structural parameters of the transition states (TSs) varied linearly with the substituent constants, with loose and tight distorted trigonal-bipyramidal TSs being formed by benzyl bromides bearing e-d and e-w groups, respectively. The reactions proceeded by SN2 mechanisms; only the transition structures were changed with the substituents and the media.

KW - Activation parameters

KW - Benzyl bromides

KW - Density functional calculations

KW - Nucleophilic substitutions

KW - Solvent effect

KW - Substituent effect

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=33845934549&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=33845934549&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1002/ejoc.200600543

DO - 10.1002/ejoc.200600543

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:33845934549

SP - 5570

EP - 5580

JO - LIEBIGS ANN. CHEM.

JF - LIEBIGS ANN. CHEM.

SN - 1434-193X

IS - 24

ER -