A Nanoindentation Approach to Assess the Mechanical Properties of Heterogeneous Biological Tissues with Poorly Defined Surface Characteristics

Preethi Chandran, Emilios K. Dimitriadis, Peter J. Basser, F. Horkay

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

Abstract

Most living tissues are composite materials with highly nonuniform material properties. Their structure and composition vary from point to point. There are also changes in strength and stiffness, with age and disease condition, which affect the biological function of the tissue. Therefore, the knowledge of tissue mechanical properties on the nano/micro scales is critically important. We have developed an approach to extract the elastic moduli of highly inhomogeneous biological tissues with surface defects that cannot be well characterized. The robustness of our method is illustrated on the example of cartilage extracellular matrix. The tissue was mildly crosslinked to prevent proteoglycan loss due to diffusion occurring upon tissue slicing. Thin tissue slices (~12 μm) have a poorly defined surface layer due to the damage and stress release caused by sectioning. Under indentation forces, the tissue exhibits apparent strain-stiffening, an artifact of the presence of this layer. Therefore, this layer must be accounted for if the properties of the intact, bulk matrix are to be correctly probed. To separate out the effect of this damaged layer, we used large indentations with the mechanics model for finite sample thickness and included an additional constant force contribution from the surface layer as well as the contact point of the underlying intact layer as fitting parameters. This in effect is equivalent to allowing for the existence of an effective\contact point that is computed as a best-fit parameter. By not forcing the fitted contact point to be on the force curve and by applying larger indentations, we obtain the elasticity of an equivalent material undergoing similar indentation but having a smooth, undamaged surface. Such an approach not only gave us an elasticity modulus that remained unchanged with indentation depth, but also had good correlation across length scales. This explains previous observations that the Hertz model cannot satisfactorily probe matrix mechanics and instead, large deformation models need to be employed (Lin et.al, Biomech. Model. Mechanobiol., 2009). Comparing the contributions from the intact matrix alone, we found that the cartilage stiffness increases towards the resting zone but decreases in the proliferative zone, even though the chemical composition does not change significantly between these regions.

Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationGels and Other Soft Amorphous Solids
EditorsEmanuela Del Gado, Ferenc Horkay, Jack F. Douglas
PublisherAmerican Chemical Society
Pages265-290
Number of pages26
ISBN (Print)9780841233164
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jan 1 2018

Publication series

NameACS Symposium Series
Volume1296
ISSN (Print)0097-6156
ISSN (Electronic)1947-5918

Fingerprint

Nanoindentation
Tissue
Mechanical properties
Indentation
Point contacts
Cartilage
Elasticity
Mechanics
Stiffness
Surface defects
Proteoglycans
Chemical analysis
Materials properties
Elastic moduli
Composite materials

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Chemistry(all)
  • Chemical Engineering(all)

Cite this

Chandran, P., Dimitriadis, E. K., Basser, P. J., & Horkay, F. (2018). A Nanoindentation Approach to Assess the Mechanical Properties of Heterogeneous Biological Tissues with Poorly Defined Surface Characteristics. In E. Del Gado, F. Horkay, & J. F. Douglas (Eds.), Gels and Other Soft Amorphous Solids (pp. 265-290). (ACS Symposium Series; Vol. 1296). American Chemical Society. https://doi.org/10.1021/bk-2018-1296.ch014

A Nanoindentation Approach to Assess the Mechanical Properties of Heterogeneous Biological Tissues with Poorly Defined Surface Characteristics. / Chandran, Preethi; Dimitriadis, Emilios K.; Basser, Peter J.; Horkay, F.

Gels and Other Soft Amorphous Solids. ed. / Emanuela Del Gado; Ferenc Horkay; Jack F. Douglas. American Chemical Society, 2018. p. 265-290 (ACS Symposium Series; Vol. 1296).

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

Chandran, P, Dimitriadis, EK, Basser, PJ & Horkay, F 2018, A Nanoindentation Approach to Assess the Mechanical Properties of Heterogeneous Biological Tissues with Poorly Defined Surface Characteristics. in E Del Gado, F Horkay & JF Douglas (eds), Gels and Other Soft Amorphous Solids. ACS Symposium Series, vol. 1296, American Chemical Society, pp. 265-290. https://doi.org/10.1021/bk-2018-1296.ch014
Chandran P, Dimitriadis EK, Basser PJ, Horkay F. A Nanoindentation Approach to Assess the Mechanical Properties of Heterogeneous Biological Tissues with Poorly Defined Surface Characteristics. In Del Gado E, Horkay F, Douglas JF, editors, Gels and Other Soft Amorphous Solids. American Chemical Society. 2018. p. 265-290. (ACS Symposium Series). https://doi.org/10.1021/bk-2018-1296.ch014
Chandran, Preethi ; Dimitriadis, Emilios K. ; Basser, Peter J. ; Horkay, F. / A Nanoindentation Approach to Assess the Mechanical Properties of Heterogeneous Biological Tissues with Poorly Defined Surface Characteristics. Gels and Other Soft Amorphous Solids. editor / Emanuela Del Gado ; Ferenc Horkay ; Jack F. Douglas. American Chemical Society, 2018. pp. 265-290 (ACS Symposium Series).
@inproceedings{5031d75dd726401c896f6da2300ce8bd,
title = "A Nanoindentation Approach to Assess the Mechanical Properties of Heterogeneous Biological Tissues with Poorly Defined Surface Characteristics",
abstract = "Most living tissues are composite materials with highly nonuniform material properties. Their structure and composition vary from point to point. There are also changes in strength and stiffness, with age and disease condition, which affect the biological function of the tissue. Therefore, the knowledge of tissue mechanical properties on the nano/micro scales is critically important. We have developed an approach to extract the elastic moduli of highly inhomogeneous biological tissues with surface defects that cannot be well characterized. The robustness of our method is illustrated on the example of cartilage extracellular matrix. The tissue was mildly crosslinked to prevent proteoglycan loss due to diffusion occurring upon tissue slicing. Thin tissue slices (~12 μm) have a poorly defined surface layer due to the damage and stress release caused by sectioning. Under indentation forces, the tissue exhibits apparent strain-stiffening, an artifact of the presence of this layer. Therefore, this layer must be accounted for if the properties of the intact, bulk matrix are to be correctly probed. To separate out the effect of this damaged layer, we used large indentations with the mechanics model for finite sample thickness and included an additional constant force contribution from the surface layer as well as the contact point of the underlying intact layer as fitting parameters. This in effect is equivalent to allowing for the existence of an effective\contact point that is computed as a best-fit parameter. By not forcing the fitted contact point to be on the force curve and by applying larger indentations, we obtain the elasticity of an equivalent material undergoing similar indentation but having a smooth, undamaged surface. Such an approach not only gave us an elasticity modulus that remained unchanged with indentation depth, but also had good correlation across length scales. This explains previous observations that the Hertz model cannot satisfactorily probe matrix mechanics and instead, large deformation models need to be employed (Lin et.al, Biomech. Model. Mechanobiol., 2009). Comparing the contributions from the intact matrix alone, we found that the cartilage stiffness increases towards the resting zone but decreases in the proliferative zone, even though the chemical composition does not change significantly between these regions.",
author = "Preethi Chandran and Dimitriadis, {Emilios K.} and Basser, {Peter J.} and F. Horkay",
year = "2018",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1021/bk-2018-1296.ch014",
language = "English",
isbn = "9780841233164",
series = "ACS Symposium Series",
publisher = "American Chemical Society",
pages = "265--290",
editor = "{Del Gado}, Emanuela and Ferenc Horkay and Douglas, {Jack F.}",
booktitle = "Gels and Other Soft Amorphous Solids",

}

TY - GEN

T1 - A Nanoindentation Approach to Assess the Mechanical Properties of Heterogeneous Biological Tissues with Poorly Defined Surface Characteristics

AU - Chandran, Preethi

AU - Dimitriadis, Emilios K.

AU - Basser, Peter J.

AU - Horkay, F.

PY - 2018/1/1

Y1 - 2018/1/1

N2 - Most living tissues are composite materials with highly nonuniform material properties. Their structure and composition vary from point to point. There are also changes in strength and stiffness, with age and disease condition, which affect the biological function of the tissue. Therefore, the knowledge of tissue mechanical properties on the nano/micro scales is critically important. We have developed an approach to extract the elastic moduli of highly inhomogeneous biological tissues with surface defects that cannot be well characterized. The robustness of our method is illustrated on the example of cartilage extracellular matrix. The tissue was mildly crosslinked to prevent proteoglycan loss due to diffusion occurring upon tissue slicing. Thin tissue slices (~12 μm) have a poorly defined surface layer due to the damage and stress release caused by sectioning. Under indentation forces, the tissue exhibits apparent strain-stiffening, an artifact of the presence of this layer. Therefore, this layer must be accounted for if the properties of the intact, bulk matrix are to be correctly probed. To separate out the effect of this damaged layer, we used large indentations with the mechanics model for finite sample thickness and included an additional constant force contribution from the surface layer as well as the contact point of the underlying intact layer as fitting parameters. This in effect is equivalent to allowing for the existence of an effective\contact point that is computed as a best-fit parameter. By not forcing the fitted contact point to be on the force curve and by applying larger indentations, we obtain the elasticity of an equivalent material undergoing similar indentation but having a smooth, undamaged surface. Such an approach not only gave us an elasticity modulus that remained unchanged with indentation depth, but also had good correlation across length scales. This explains previous observations that the Hertz model cannot satisfactorily probe matrix mechanics and instead, large deformation models need to be employed (Lin et.al, Biomech. Model. Mechanobiol., 2009). Comparing the contributions from the intact matrix alone, we found that the cartilage stiffness increases towards the resting zone but decreases in the proliferative zone, even though the chemical composition does not change significantly between these regions.

AB - Most living tissues are composite materials with highly nonuniform material properties. Their structure and composition vary from point to point. There are also changes in strength and stiffness, with age and disease condition, which affect the biological function of the tissue. Therefore, the knowledge of tissue mechanical properties on the nano/micro scales is critically important. We have developed an approach to extract the elastic moduli of highly inhomogeneous biological tissues with surface defects that cannot be well characterized. The robustness of our method is illustrated on the example of cartilage extracellular matrix. The tissue was mildly crosslinked to prevent proteoglycan loss due to diffusion occurring upon tissue slicing. Thin tissue slices (~12 μm) have a poorly defined surface layer due to the damage and stress release caused by sectioning. Under indentation forces, the tissue exhibits apparent strain-stiffening, an artifact of the presence of this layer. Therefore, this layer must be accounted for if the properties of the intact, bulk matrix are to be correctly probed. To separate out the effect of this damaged layer, we used large indentations with the mechanics model for finite sample thickness and included an additional constant force contribution from the surface layer as well as the contact point of the underlying intact layer as fitting parameters. This in effect is equivalent to allowing for the existence of an effective\contact point that is computed as a best-fit parameter. By not forcing the fitted contact point to be on the force curve and by applying larger indentations, we obtain the elasticity of an equivalent material undergoing similar indentation but having a smooth, undamaged surface. Such an approach not only gave us an elasticity modulus that remained unchanged with indentation depth, but also had good correlation across length scales. This explains previous observations that the Hertz model cannot satisfactorily probe matrix mechanics and instead, large deformation models need to be employed (Lin et.al, Biomech. Model. Mechanobiol., 2009). Comparing the contributions from the intact matrix alone, we found that the cartilage stiffness increases towards the resting zone but decreases in the proliferative zone, even though the chemical composition does not change significantly between these regions.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85052625113&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85052625113&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1021/bk-2018-1296.ch014

DO - 10.1021/bk-2018-1296.ch014

M3 - Conference contribution

AN - SCOPUS:85052625113

SN - 9780841233164

T3 - ACS Symposium Series

SP - 265

EP - 290

BT - Gels and Other Soft Amorphous Solids

A2 - Del Gado, Emanuela

A2 - Horkay, Ferenc

A2 - Douglas, Jack F.

PB - American Chemical Society

ER -